Auto merge of rust-lang#133929 - saethlin:remove-inline-in-all-cgus, …

…r=<try>

Remove -Zinline-in-all-cgus and clean up tests/codegen-units/

Implementation of rust-lang/compiler-team#814

I've taken some liberties with cleaning up the CGU partitioning tests, because that's the only place this flag was used and also mattered. I've often fought a lot with the contents of `tests/codegen-units` and it has never been clear to me when a test failure indicates a problem with my changes as opposed to a test just needing to be manually blessed. Hopefully the combination of the new README, new comments, and using `-Zprint-mono-items=lazy` in the partitioning tests improves that.

I've also deleted some of the `tests/run-make/sepcomp` tests. I think all the "sepcomp" tests have been obviated for years by better-designed (less flaky, clearer failures) test suites, but here I'm just deleting the ones I'm confident in.

try-job: x86_64-gnu-nopt

compiler/rustc_interface/src/tests.rs

@@ -797,7 +797,6 @@ fn test_unstable_options_tracking_hash() {
     tracked!(function_sections, Some(false));
     tracked!(human_readable_cgu_names, true);
     tracked!(incremental_ignore_spans, true);
-    tracked!(inline_in_all_cgus, Some(true));
     tracked!(inline_mir, Some(true));
     tracked!(inline_mir_hint_threshold, Some(123));
     tracked!(inline_mir_threshold, Some(123));

compiler/rustc_middle/src/mir/mono.rs

@@ -91,13 +91,8 @@ impl<'tcx> MonoItem<'tcx> {
     }
 
     pub fn instantiation_mode(&self, tcx: TyCtxt<'tcx>) -> InstantiationMode {
-        let generate_cgu_internal_copies = tcx
-            .sess
-            .opts
-            .unstable_opts
-            .inline_in_all_cgus
-            .unwrap_or_else(|| tcx.sess.opts.optimize != OptLevel::No)
-            && !tcx.sess.link_dead_code();
+        let generate_cgu_internal_copies =
+            (tcx.sess.opts.optimize != OptLevel::No) && !tcx.sess.link_dead_code();
 
         match *self {
             MonoItem::Fn(ref instance) => {
@@ -121,8 +116,8 @@ impl<'tcx> MonoItem<'tcx> {
                 }
 
                 // At this point we don't have explicit linkage and we're an
-                // inlined function. If we're inlining into all CGUs then we'll
-                // be creating a local copy per CGU.
+                // inlined function. If this crate's build settings permit,
+                // we'll be creating a local copy per CGU.
                 if generate_cgu_internal_copies {
                     return InstantiationMode::LocalCopy;
                 }

compiler/rustc_session/src/options.rs

@@ -1870,8 +1870,6 @@ options! {
         "verify extended properties for incr. comp. (default: no):
         - hashes of green query instances
         - hash collisions of query keys"),
-    inline_in_all_cgus: Option<bool> = (None, parse_opt_bool, [TRACKED],
-        "control whether `#[inline]` functions are in all CGUs"),
     inline_llvm: bool = (true, parse_bool, [TRACKED],
         "enable LLVM inlining (default: yes)"),
     inline_mir: Option<bool> = (None, parse_opt_bool, [TRACKED],

tests/codegen-units/item-collection/drop_in_place_intrinsic.rs

@@ -1,7 +1,6 @@
-//
 //@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=eager
-//@ compile-flags:-Zinline-in-all-cgus
 //@ compile-flags:-Zinline-mir=no
+//@ compile-flags: -O
 
 #![crate_type = "lib"]
 

tests/codegen-units/item-collection/generic-drop-glue.rs

@@ -1,6 +1,5 @@
-//
 //@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=eager
-//@ compile-flags:-Zinline-in-all-cgus
+//@ compile-flags: -O
 
 #![deny(dead_code)]
 #![crate_type = "lib"]

tests/codegen-units/item-collection/instantiation-through-vtable.rs

@@ -1,5 +1,4 @@
-//
-//@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=eager -Zinline-in-all-cgus -Zmir-opt-level=0
+//@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=eager -Zmir-opt-level=0
 
 #![deny(dead_code)]
 #![crate_type = "lib"]

tests/codegen-units/item-collection/non-generic-drop-glue.rs

@@ -1,6 +1,5 @@
-//
 //@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=eager
-//@ compile-flags:-Zinline-in-all-cgus
+//@ compile-flags: -O
 
 #![deny(dead_code)]
 #![crate_type = "lib"]

tests/codegen-units/item-collection/transitive-drop-glue.rs

@@ -1,6 +1,5 @@
-//
 //@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=eager
-//@ compile-flags:-Zinline-in-all-cgus
+//@ compile-flags: -O
 
 #![deny(dead_code)]
 #![crate_type = "lib"]

tests/codegen-units/item-collection/tuple-drop-glue.rs

@@ -1,6 +1,5 @@
-//
 //@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=eager
-//@ compile-flags:-Zinline-in-all-cgus
+//@ compile-flags: -O
 
 #![deny(dead_code)]
 #![crate_type = "lib"]

tests/codegen-units/item-collection/unsizing.rs

@@ -1,5 +1,4 @@
 //@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=eager
-//@ compile-flags:-Zinline-in-all-cgus
 //@ compile-flags:-Zmir-opt-level=0
 
 #![deny(dead_code)]

tests/codegen-units/partitioning/README.md

@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+# codegen-units/partitioning tests
+
+This test suite is designed to test that codegen unit partitioning works as intended.
+Note that it does not evaluate whether CGU partitioning is *good*. That is the job of the compiler benchmark suite.
+
+All tests in this suite use the flag `-Zprint-mono-items=lazy`, which makes the compiler print a machine-readable summary of all MonoItems that were collected, which CGUs they were assigned to, and the linkage in each CGU. The output looks like:
+```
+MONO_ITEM <item> @@ <cgu name>[<linkage>] <other cgu name>[<linkage in other cgu>]
+```
+DO NOT add tests to this suite that use `-Zprint-mono-items=eager`. That flag changes the way that MonoItem collection works in rather fundamental ways that are otherwise only used by `-Clink-dead-code`, and thus the MonoItems collected and their linkage under `-Zprint-mono-items=eager` does not correlate very well with normal compilation behavior.
+
+The current CGU partitioning algorithm essentially groups MonoItems by which module they are defined in, then merges small CGUs. There are a lot of inline modules in this test suite because that's the only way to observe the partitioning.
+
+Currently, the test suite is very heavily biased towards incremental builds with -Copt-level=0. This is mostly an accident of history; the entire test suite was added as part of supporting incremental compilation in #32779. But also CGU partitioning is *mostly* valuable because the CGU is the unit of incrementality to the codegen backend (cached queries are the unit of incrementality for the rest of the compiler).

tests/codegen-units/partitioning/auxiliary/shared_generics_aux.rs

@@ -1,7 +1,6 @@
 // NOTE: We always compile this test with -Copt-level=0 because higher opt-levels
 //       prevent drop-glue from participating in share-generics.
-//@ compile-flags:-Zshare-generics=yes -Copt-level=0
-//@ no-prefer-dynamic
+//@ compile-flags: -Zshare-generics=yes -Copt-level=0
 
 #![crate_type = "rlib"]
 

tests/codegen-units/partitioning/extern-drop-glue.rs

@@ -1,15 +1,14 @@
-// We specify incremental here because we want to test the partitioning for incremental compilation
-// We specify opt-level=0 because `drop_in_place` is `Internal` when optimizing
 //@ incremental
-//@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=lazy
-//@ compile-flags:-Zinline-in-all-cgus -Copt-level=0
+//@ compile-flags: -Zprint-mono-items=lazy -Copt-level=0
 
-#![allow(dead_code)]
 #![crate_type = "rlib"]
 
 //@ aux-build:cgu_extern_drop_glue.rs
 extern crate cgu_extern_drop_glue;
 
+// This test checks that drop glue is generated, even for types not defined in this crate, and all
+// drop glue is put in the fallback CGU.
+
 //~ MONO_ITEM fn std::ptr::drop_in_place::<cgu_extern_drop_glue::Struct> - shim(Some(cgu_extern_drop_glue::Struct)) @@ extern_drop_glue-fallback.cgu[External]
 
 struct LocalStruct(cgu_extern_drop_glue::Struct);

tests/codegen-units/partitioning/extern-generic.rs

@@ -1,51 +1,36 @@
-// We specify incremental here because we want to test the partitioning for incremental compilation
 //@ incremental
-//@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=eager -Zshare-generics=y
+//@ compile-flags: -Zprint-mono-items=lazy -Copt-level=0
 
-#![allow(dead_code)]
 #![crate_type = "lib"]
 
 //@ aux-build:cgu_generic_function.rs
 extern crate cgu_generic_function;
 
-//~ MONO_ITEM fn user @@ extern_generic[Internal]
-fn user() {
+// This test checks that, in an unoptimized build, a generic function and its callees are only
+// instantiated once in this crate.
+
+//~ MONO_ITEM fn user @@ extern_generic[External]
+pub fn user() {
     let _ = cgu_generic_function::foo("abc");
 }
 
-mod mod1 {
+pub mod mod1 {
     use cgu_generic_function;
 
-    //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod1::user @@ extern_generic-mod1[Internal]
-    fn user() {
+    //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod1::user @@ extern_generic-mod1[External]
+    pub fn user() {
         let _ = cgu_generic_function::foo("abc");
     }
 
-    mod mod1 {
+    pub mod mod1 {
         use cgu_generic_function;
 
-        //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod1::mod1::user @@ extern_generic-mod1-mod1[Internal]
-        fn user() {
+        //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod1::mod1::user @@ extern_generic-mod1-mod1[External]
+        pub fn user() {
             let _ = cgu_generic_function::foo("abc");
         }
     }
 }
 
-mod mod2 {
-    use cgu_generic_function;
-
-    //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod2::user @@ extern_generic-mod2[Internal]
-    fn user() {
-        let _ = cgu_generic_function::foo("abc");
-    }
-}
-
-mod mod3 {
-    //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod3::non_user @@ extern_generic-mod3[Internal]
-    fn non_user() {}
-}
-
-// Make sure the two generic functions from the extern crate get instantiated
-// once for the current crate
 //~ MONO_ITEM fn cgu_generic_function::foo::<&str> @@ cgu_generic_function-in-extern_generic.volatile[External]
 //~ MONO_ITEM fn cgu_generic_function::bar::<&str> @@ cgu_generic_function-in-extern_generic.volatile[External]

tests/codegen-units/partitioning/incremental-merging.rs

@@ -1,16 +1,15 @@
-// We specify incremental here because we want to test the partitioning for incremental compilation
 //@ incremental
-//@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=lazy
-//@ compile-flags:-Ccodegen-units=3
+//@ compile-flags: -Zprint-mono-items=lazy -Copt-level=0 -Ccodegen-units=3
 
 #![crate_type = "rlib"]
 
 // This test makes sure that merging of CGUs works together with incremental
 // compilation but at the same time does not modify names of CGUs that were not
 // affected by merging.
 //
-// We expect CGUs `aaa` and `bbb` to be merged (because they are the smallest),
-// while `ccc` and `ddd` are supposed to stay untouched.
+// CGU partitioning creates one CGU per module, so with 4 modules and codegen-units=3,
+// two of the modules should be merged. We expect CGUs `aaa` and `bbb` to be merged
+// (because they are the smallest), while `ccc` and `ddd` should stay untouched.
 
 pub mod aaa {
     //~ MONO_ITEM fn aaa::foo @@ incremental_merging-aaa--incremental_merging-bbb[External]

tests/codegen-units/partitioning/inline-always.rs

@@ -0,0 +1,38 @@
+//@ incremental
+//@ compile-flags: -Zprint-mono-items=lazy -Copt-level=0
+
+#![crate_type = "lib"]
+
+// This test checks that a monomorphic inline(always) function is instantiated in every CGU that
+// references it, even though this is an unoptimized incremental build.
+// It also checks that an inline(always) function is only placed in CGUs that reference it.
+
+mod inline {
+    //~ MONO_ITEM fn inline::inlined_function @@ inline_always-user1[Internal] inline_always-user2[Internal]
+    #[inline(always)]
+    pub fn inlined_function() {}
+}
+
+pub mod user1 {
+    use super::inline;
+
+    //~ MONO_ITEM fn user1::foo @@ inline_always-user1[External]
+    pub fn foo() {
+        inline::inlined_function();
+    }
+}
+
+pub mod user2 {
+    use super::inline;
+
+    //~ MONO_ITEM fn user2::bar @@ inline_always-user2[External]
+    pub fn bar() {
+        inline::inlined_function();
+    }
+}
+
+pub mod non_user {
+
+    //~ MONO_ITEM fn non_user::baz @@ inline_always-non_user[External]
+    pub fn baz() {}
+}

tests/codegen-units/partitioning/inlining-from-extern-crate.rs

@@ -1,7 +1,5 @@
-// We specify incremental here because we want to test the partitioning for incremental compilation
 //@ incremental
-//@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=lazy
-//@ compile-flags:-Zinline-in-all-cgus
+//@ compile-flags: -Zprint-mono-items=lazy -Copt-level=1
 
 #![crate_type = "lib"]
 

tests/codegen-units/partitioning/local-drop-glue.rs

@@ -1,14 +1,14 @@
-// We specify incremental here because we want to test the partitioning for incremental compilation
-// We specify opt-level=0 because `drop_in_place` is `Internal` when optimizing
 //@ incremental
-//@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=lazy
-//@ compile-flags:-Zinline-in-all-cgus -Copt-level=0
+//@ compile-flags: -Zprint-mono-items=lazy -Copt-level=0
 
-#![allow(dead_code)]
 #![crate_type = "rlib"]
 
+// This test checks that drop glue is generated for types defined in this crate, and that all drop
+// glue is put in the fallback CGU.
+// This is rather similar to extern-drop-glue.rs.
+
 //~ MONO_ITEM fn std::ptr::drop_in_place::<Struct> - shim(Some(Struct)) @@ local_drop_glue-fallback.cgu[External]
-struct Struct {
+pub struct Struct {
     _a: u32,
 }
 
@@ -18,7 +18,7 @@ impl Drop for Struct {
 }
 
 //~ MONO_ITEM fn std::ptr::drop_in_place::<Outer> - shim(Some(Outer)) @@ local_drop_glue-fallback.cgu[External]
-struct Outer {
+pub struct Outer {
     _a: Struct,
 }
 
@@ -33,7 +33,7 @@ pub mod mod1 {
     //~ MONO_ITEM fn std::ptr::drop_in_place::<mod1::Struct2> - shim(Some(mod1::Struct2)) @@ local_drop_glue-fallback.cgu[External]
     struct Struct2 {
         _a: Struct,
-        //~ MONO_ITEM fn std::ptr::drop_in_place::<(u32, Struct)> - shim(Some((u32, Struct))) @@ local_drop_glue-fallback.cgu[Internal]
+        //~ MONO_ITEM fn std::ptr::drop_in_place::<(u32, Struct)> - shim(Some((u32, Struct))) @@ local_drop_glue-fallback.cgu[External]
         _b: (u32, Struct),
     }
 

tests/codegen-units/partitioning/local-generic.rs

@@ -1,10 +1,11 @@
-// We specify incremental here because we want to test the partitioning for incremental compilation
 //@ incremental
-//@ compile-flags:-Zprint-mono-items=eager
+//@ compile-flags: -Zprint-mono-items=lazy -Copt-level=0
 
-#![allow(dead_code)]
 #![crate_type = "lib"]
 
+// This test checks that all the instantiations of a local generic fn are placed in the same CGU,
+// regardless of where it is called.
+
 //~ MONO_ITEM fn generic::<u32> @@ local_generic.volatile[External]
 //~ MONO_ITEM fn generic::<u64> @@ local_generic.volatile[External]
 //~ MONO_ITEM fn generic::<char> @@ local_generic.volatile[External]
@@ -13,34 +14,34 @@ pub fn generic<T>(x: T) -> T {
     x
 }
 
-//~ MONO_ITEM fn user @@ local_generic[Internal]
-fn user() {
+//~ MONO_ITEM fn user @@ local_generic[External]
+pub fn user() {
     let _ = generic(0u32);
 }
 
-mod mod1 {
+pub mod mod1 {
     pub use super::generic;
 
-    //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod1::user @@ local_generic-mod1[Internal]
-    fn user() {
+    //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod1::user @@ local_generic-mod1[External]
+    pub fn user() {
         let _ = generic(0u64);
     }
 
-    mod mod1 {
+    pub mod mod1 {
         use super::generic;
 
-        //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod1::mod1::user @@ local_generic-mod1-mod1[Internal]
-        fn user() {
+        //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod1::mod1::user @@ local_generic-mod1-mod1[External]
+        pub fn user() {
             let _ = generic('c');
         }
     }
 }
 
-mod mod2 {
+pub mod mod2 {
     use super::generic;
 
-    //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod2::user @@ local_generic-mod2[Internal]
-    fn user() {
+    //~ MONO_ITEM fn mod2::user @@ local_generic-mod2[External]
+    pub fn user() {
         let _ = generic("abc");
     }
 }