[CLI] Improve ray status for placement groups

[rkooo567]

Why are these changes needed?

• For no node type, we format resources in a prettier way. It also displays how many of resources are reserved by pgs.
• For usage, it includes usage / total of placement group. Previously, it only prints the "usage" of placement group, which was confusing

After

Node status
------------------------------------------------------------
 1 node(s) with resources:
  CPU: 3.0
  object_store_memory: 157286400.0
  GPU: 66.0 (66.0 reserved in placement groups)
  pg_custom: 66.0 (66.0 reserved in placement groups)
  node:192.168.1.3: 1.0
  memory: 8279552000.0

Resources
------------------------------------------------------------
Usage:
 0.0/3.0 CPU
 66.0/66.0 GPU (0.0/66.0 used by placement groups)
 0.00/7.711 GiB memory
 0.00/0.146 GiB object_store_memory
 66.0/66.0 pg_custom (0.0/66.0 used by placement groups)

Before

Node status
------------------------------------------------------------
 1 node(s) with resources: {'GPU_group_0_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1.0, 'GPU_group_3_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1.0, 'GPU_group_3_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 5.0, 'pg_custom_group_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 5.0, 'bundle_group_3_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_0_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1.0, 'bundle_group_2_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_3_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1.0, 'bundle_group_2_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_3_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_2_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1.0, 'bundle_group_1_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 5000.0, 'bundle_group_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 5000.0, 'bundle_group_4_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 5.0, 'pg_custom_group_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 5.0, 'GPU_group_4_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1.0, 'bundle_group_1_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 5.0, 'GPU_group_2_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1.0, 'bundle_group_4_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_3_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1.0, 'bundle_group_3_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_4_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 5.0, 'GPU_group_0_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 5.0, 'bundle_group_4_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_26addd2b76ca2377438e18791ea0b8f4': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 5.0, 'GPU_group_0_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1.0, 'GPU_group_4_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1.0, 'CPU': 3.0, 'bundle_group_4_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_1_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_4_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1.0, 'bundle_group_0_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_1_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 5.0, 'GPU_group_3_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1.0, 'bundle_group_4_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1.0, 'GPU_group_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 5.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1.0, 'GPU_group_2_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1.0, 'bundle_group_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 5000.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1.0, 'bundle_group_0_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 5.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1.0, 'bundle_group_1_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_0_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1.0, 'GPU_group_4_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1.0, 'bundle_group_1_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 5.0, 'GPU_group_1_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1.0, 'bundle_group_3_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1.0, 'GPU_group_2_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1.0, 'GPU_group_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 5.0, 'pg_custom_group_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 5.0, 'object_store_memory': 157286400.0, 'bundle_group_2_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_3_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_26addd2b76ca2377438e18791ea0b8f4': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1.0, 'bundle_group_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 5000.0, 'bundle_group_3_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1.0, 'bundle_group_0_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_4_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 5.0, 'GPU': 66.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1.0, 'GPU_group_1_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1.0, 'bundle_group_3_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1.0, 'GPU_group_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 5.0, 'GPU_group_3_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1.0, 'GPU_group_4_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1.0, 'GPU_group_1_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1.0, 'bundle_group_3_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_4_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1000.0, 'pg_custom': 66.0, 'bundle_group_1_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 5000.0, 'bundle_group_2_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_1_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 5.0, 'bundle_group_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 5000.0, 'bundle_group_0_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_2_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_0_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_0_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1.0, 'bundle_group_2_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 5000.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1.0, 'GPU_group_4_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1.0, 'bundle_group_26addd2b76ca2377438e18791ea0b8f4': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_2_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1.0, 'bundle_group_1_26addd2b76ca2377438e18791ea0b8f4': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_1_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1.0, 'bundle_group_2_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1.0, 'bundle_group_1_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_2_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1.0, 'GPU_group_0_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1.0, 'bundle_group_3_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1.0, 'GPU_group_4_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1.0, 'GPU_group_0_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1.0, 'GPU_group_3_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 5.0, 'GPU_group_1_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1.0, 'GPU_group_2_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1.0, 'bundle_group_1_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1.0, 'bundle_group_0_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_2_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1.0, 'GPU_group_4_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1.0, 'bundle_group_3_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1.0, 'GPU_group_4_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1.0, 'GPU_group_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 5.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1.0, 'bundle_group_4_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1.0, 'GPU_group_2_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1.0, 'bundle_group_4_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_3_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 5.0, 'GPU_group_1_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1.0, 'bundle_group_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 5000.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1.0, 'bundle_group_0_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 5.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1.0, 'bundle_group_0_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_2_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_1_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_0_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_0_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_3_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 5.0, 'GPU_group_1_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1.0, 'bundle_group_0_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_2_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1.0, 'bundle_group_2_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_2_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1.0, 'GPU_group_26addd2b76ca2377438e18791ea0b8f4': 1.0, 'bundle_group_2_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_4_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_2_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1.0, 'GPU_group_1_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_1_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1.0, 'bundle_group_4_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1000.0, 'bundle_group_2_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1.0, 'GPU_group_3_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1.0, 'bundle_group_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 5000.0, 'bundle_group_4_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1.0, 'GPU_group_3_efb63fec901c967f94cb97a3928d52cf': 1.0, 'GPU_group_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 5.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1.0, 'GPU_group_1_26addd2b76ca2377438e18791ea0b8f4': 1.0, 'GPU_group_2_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1.0, 'node:192.168.1.3': 1.0, 'GPU_group_4_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1.0, 'bundle_group_1_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_4_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1.0, 'GPU_group_1_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1.0, 'memory': 8279552000.0, 'bundle_group_4_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_2_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1.0, 'GPU_group_2_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1.0, 'GPU_group_1_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1.0, 'bundle_group_0_4acd757a53c53f736b72800076076b53': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1.0, 'GPU_group_3_e6314fb8a23d64a2df3b6c92a2d03821': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 1.0, 'GPU_group_0_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1.0, 'GPU_group_1_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_4_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1.0, 'bundle_group_3_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1000.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 1.0, 'GPU_group_0_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1.0, 'GPU_group_0_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1.0, 'GPU_group_b47fe6e409dab4c127d34d05cf29017a': 5.0, 'GPU_group_1_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1.0, 'GPU_group_3_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1.0, 'GPU_group_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 5.0, 'bundle_group_1_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_4_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1.0, 'bundle_group_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 5000.0, 'bundle_group_326f40a13dccec23e14b78fc80262f71': 5000.0, 'GPU_group_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 5.0, 'pg_custom_group_0_d6975df5cdeda9b201fb62beb6311494': 1.0, 'bundle_group_3_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 1000.0, 'GPU_group_2_9da53bf2a1710a4433453f8e072ef810': 1.0, 'GPU_group_3_6e150e681d33f39699685637ca0fdc5b': 1.0, 'GPU_group_0_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1.0, 'GPU_group_0_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 1.0, 'GPU_group_1_868294ac2d7a48c9447a16e7e915bd54': 1.0, 'pg_custom_group_3_080c9d088f3049e7bb4139a4c9fdba1a': 1.0, 'bundle_group_9d3bd7eb3e3d432729bccf4ae30568d7': 5000.0, 'bundle_group_76cfbe45659a1252fd4fe2f695ddd026': 5000.0, 'GPU_group_0_e17ecaca21cc323f91f83f01a5d3f376': 1.0}

Resources
------------------------------------------------------------
Usage:
 0.0/3.0 CPU
 66.0/66.0 GPU
 0.00/7.711 GiB memory
 0.00/0.146 GiB object_store_memory
 66.0/66.0 pg_custom

Related issue number

Checks

• I've run scripts/format.sh to lint the changes in this PR.
• I've included any doc changes needed for https://docs.ray.io/en/master/.
• I've made sure the tests are passing. Note that there might be a few flaky tests, see the recent failures at https://flakey-tests.ray.io/
• Testing Strategy
  • Unit tests
  • Release tests
  • This PR is not tested :(

[rkooo567]

Btw, this is still confusing;

66.0/66.0 GPU (0.0/66.0 used by placement groups)

We uses 66 GPUs because they are all reserved by placement groups. I was thinking

0.0/0.0 GPU
0.0/66.0 GPU (reserved by placement groups)

this as an alternative format, but haven't implemented it because this can also be confusing...

[ericl]

test_cli failing

[ericl]

66.0/66.0 GPU (0.0/66.0 used by placement groups)

This doesn't grammatically make sense. Does it mean 66 is reserved in placement groups, but 0 is used within the group?

[ericl]

Comment

[ericl]

See comments

[rkooo567]

@ericl

This doesn't grammatically make sense. Does it mean 66 is reserved in placement groups, but 0 is used within the group?

Yes. Right now the representation is

 66.0/66.0 GPU (X reserved in placement groups)

where X is "used" resources in placement groups.

and this will become

66.0/66.6 GPU (X/66.0 used in placement groups).

I agree this rep is a little weird. Another alternative is

1. Separate out resources used by pgs

0.0/0.0 GPU # Original resources
X/66.0 GPU (reserved by placement groups) # PG reserved resources

or

2. Use total reserved amount in the paranthesis and instead use the real usage

Y/66.0 GPU (66.0 reserved in placement groups) # Y == used (66) - pg_reserved (66) + pg_used (X)

One con of this option is that when your usages are mixed up with placement group usages, it is hard to read. Imagine

X CPU
Y Reserved
Z Used by pg

X + Z / 66.0 (Y reserved in placement groups) # but it is hard to know what are used by pg and what are not

[ericl]

I vote for (2)

…

On Thu, Sep 2, 2021, 4:38 PM SangBin Cho ***@***.***> wrote: @ericl <https://github.com/ericl> This doesn't grammatically make sense. Does it mean 66 is reserved in placement groups, but 0 is used within the group? Yes. Right now the representation is 66.0/66.0 GPU (X reserved in placement groups) where X is "used" resources in placement groups. and this will become 66.0/66.6 GPU (X/66.0 used in placement groups). I agree this rep is a little weird. Another alternative is 1. Separate out resources used by pgs 0.0/0.0 GPU # Original resources 0.0/66.0 GPU (reserved by placement groups) # PG reserved resources or 1. Use total reserved amount in the paranthesis and instead use the real usage X/66.0 GPU (66.0 reserved in placement groups) # X == used - pg_reserved + pg_used — You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#18289 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAADUSSATLWMISU2EPJUJ4DUAADHLANCNFSM5DHQXLNA> . Triage notifications on the go with GitHub Mobile for iOS <https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id1477376905?ct=notification-email&mt=8&pt=524675> or Android <https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.github.android&referrer=utm_campaign%3Dnotification-email%26utm_medium%3Demail%26utm_source%3Dgithub>.

[rkooo567]

@ericl @scv119 I'd like to get some final thoughts; I am thinking this;

66 CPU
56 pg reserved
4 used by CPU
40 used by pg reserved

# Current
60.0/66.0 (40 reserved in placement groups)

# New proposal
44.0/66.0 CPU (40 used, 56.0 reserved in placement groups )

Thought?

[ericl]

LGTM. The extra redundancy helps understanding.

…

On Thu, Sep 2, 2021, 11:18 PM SangBin Cho ***@***.***> wrote: @ericl <https://github.com/ericl> @scv119 <https://github.com/scv119> I'd like to get some final thoughts; I am thinking this; 66 CPU 56 pg reserved 4 used by CPU 40 used by pg reserved # Current 60.0/66.0 (40 reserved in placement groups) # New proposal 44.0/66.0 CPU (40 used, 56.0 reserved in placement groups ) Thought? — You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#18289 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAADUSROEWJQL5J5RJ4WVCLUABSD5ANCNFSM5DHQXLNA> . Triage notifications on the go with GitHub Mobile for iOS <https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id1477376905?ct=notification-email&mt=8&pt=524675> or Android <https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.github.android&referrer=utm_campaign%3Dnotification-email%26utm_medium%3Demail%26utm_source%3Dgithub>.