-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 301
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Google Domains #2900
Comments
Thank you @Retold3202, great work as always. We'll take a closer look. |
I recently dug up an old Stock Android phone I've had lying around, so I've been doing some experimenting & testing with it, and I found a couple more domains & more info.
There were a few other interesting domains I found as well that caught my eye, but I need to find more info on them, will probably further investigate tomorrow & report back with my findings. :) |
Thanks for the details @Retold3202 - great. I have added I will not completely block Google Maps Timeline through |
@Retold3202 Can you confirm that There is also |
I tried blocking
I noticed this one as well. After some digging, it looks like it's part of Firebase Cloud Messaging according to Google's docs here, so that would make sense with it breaking push notifications for you there. We should probably just leave it alone. |
Many thanks @Retold3202, |
Always glad to help @hagezi :) I'm currently investigating these domains, but they're very difficult to find info on and I'm struggling to get them to reproduce, so I'll go ahead and post them here in case you or anyone else who stumbles upon this has any info on them:
Some of these Google domains have been extremely difficult to find info on, they lack documentation, I've even dug through Google's developer resources. I'll keep experimenting around & investigating. |
A couple more discoveries:
|
@Retold3202 I had personally blocked voilatile-pa.googleapis.com in the past but I then whitelisted it because, if I remember right, after some days Google Play Store showed "Device not certified" under Play Protect Certification |
Regarding locationhistory-pa.googleapis.com, this seems really sketchy, my device tries to call it two times a day even if I have location history (Timeline) disabled |
I would also consider blocking: content-autofill.googleapis.com I have these blocked for months and I didn't notice any problem, but I also don't use most of google services, so some investigation is needed. |
I've had it blocked on my device for around a week now, and I just took a look, and it appears to still show as "Certified". So it might've just been a coincidence, or maybe it's something different in my case. Some of these Google domains are probably the hardest I've ever tried researching/finding info on, a lot of them are fairly sketchy IMO and there's near no info anywhere on a lot of them unfortunately.
I'm fairly certain this is related to the "Autofill with Google" feature on Android. Personally I could care less about it and I block it on my personal list, but I doubt Hagezi will want to block this for the masses since this could be a legitimate feature people are using.
This appears to be related to geolocation (ex. Page 3 here). As to what its purpose is... your guess is as good as mine. 🤷♀️ I've had it blocked and haven't noticed any issues, looks like you have as well, but certainly needs more investigation.
This is definitely a sketchy one, I've ran into it myself and spent a lot of time researching it. After some more research, according to Page 53 here, this appears to be another form of telemetry & was caught here sending the list of installed apps to Google. I haven't encountered any issues with this blocked, & you said you haven't either, so I think we should probably consider blocking this on the lists.
Another domain with absolutely no info on it anywhere. Definitely needs investigation.
This is probably related to Google Chrome Sync. This is another case where I doubt Hagezi will block it for the masses since it could be a legitimate feature that people are using. I'll probably add it to my personal blocklist though because I could care less about it.
This is definitely another sketchy one. It appears to be required for Google's "Quick Share" feature to work (ex. here), but this does also appear to be used for advertising & tracking. I think we should block it on the more aggressive lists.
This shouldn't be blocked, it's part of Android's Remote Provisioning Attestation feature, which is useful from a security perspective & for checking device integrity. |
Also looks like I was 100% correct about
|
As an aside, I think we should also consider blocking:
|
In 4268492 I have made a few adjustments based on the comments. Thanks @AleIlMagno and @Retold3202. |
Allowing these 2 domains in NextDNS helps my Google Maps & Taxi, Cab, Ride Hailing apps work.
Those 2 domains were not blocked in the previous Ultimate filter according to my NextDNS logs. |
This issue has been fixed in release 2025.014.74415 |
I just found this in the logs: According to ChatGPT Search:
|
ChatGPT is incorrect. |
Oh okay, we should leave it as is then, sorry
|
ref: Blocking |
Any information about I've been blocking it from Spotify for a few days, apparently with no loss of functionality. Saw it accessed by various Google services (not just photos) in the browser. |
@hagezi I get "This thread does not exist" when I follow that link. When I searched for the domain name, Perplexity regurgitated what we already know:
|
Your device is likely calling peoplestackwebexperiments-pa.clients6.google.com as part of Google's services, specifically related to Google Photos Face Grouping. This feature uses facial recognition to organize photos, even if you do not actively use Google Photos. The subdomain may be accessed by background processes linked to Google Play Services or other pre-installed Google apps that rely on shared infrastructure for functionality like syncing, telemetry, or AI-based features 1 2 7. If you have disabled most Google apps or do not use Google Photos, these calls could still occur due to residual dependencies in the operating system or apps that interact with Google's services. Blocking this domain may not disrupt your device's core functions but could affect specific features tied to Google's ecosystem 2 5. |
That surprises me to hear it’s being called by Spotify, I’m not sure why third party services would be using it. Regardless, I would be in favor of blocking |
Can you check the domain above as well? |
No blocking! No blocking!
|
I noticed
It looks like
|
…lists#2900 (comment) Signed-off-by: celenity <[email protected]>
…ication-pa-prod.sandbox.googleapis.com` on Personal - hagezi/dns-blocklists#2900 (comment) Signed-off-by: celenity <[email protected]>
Thanks @celenityy, I will add
to the Ultimate. @Seohare |
If this domain is also identified as a tracker, please include it in the list |
My device is a laptop running Fedora, and I don't use any Google applications outside of a browser. I do develop code that make API calls to Firebase and Google Auth, but that's it.
This might be an issue with the firewall I'm using - mis-identifying the application. |
@celenityy: Spotify uses the Chromium Embedded Framework, so it might be Chromium phoning home. |
Which domain(s) should be blocked?
auditrecording-pa.googleapis.com
clienttracing-pa.googleapis.com
datasaver.googleapis.com
feedback-pa.googleapis.com
growth-pa.googleapis.com
gvt2-cn.com
gvt3.com
locationhistory-pa.googleapis.com
locationhistoryaggregates-pa.googleapis.com
Why should these domain(s) be blocked?
auditrecording-pa.googleapis.com
- It looks like this is already blocked onUltimate
, but I think it might be worth blocking this on some of the less aggressive lists as well. This appears to be related to Google's Cloud Audit Logging API: https://cloud.google.com/logging/docs/audit, so it's just more telemetry. I was also able to find more info on it proving this further here on Page 34 & Page 36. We can see:POST https://auditrecording−pa.googleapis.com/google.internal.api.auditrecording.v1.AuditRecordingMobileService/CreateAuditRecord POST body: <binary payload>
&POST https://auditrecording−pa.googleapis.com/google.internal.api. auditrecording.v1.AuditRecordingMobileService/CreateAuditRecord Headers x−goog−spatula: CjYKFmNvbS5nb29n...Fwu6/s+CCz+wBKgA= POST body decoded as protobuf: <...> <device details> <...>
.clienttracing-pa.googleapis.com
- I've noticed Stock Android devices phone home to this, difficult to find info on, but it seems to be related to Google's Cloud Trace API, so just more telemetry.datasaver.googleapis.com
- This is related to Chromium's "Data Saver" feature, I think we should really consider blocking this one, at least on the more aggressive lists. You can see here for more info, but this is extremely concerning from a privacy & security standpoint... Google is not only sent the websites you visit, but literally MITMs them.feedback-pa.googleapis.com
- I've noticed Google apps on iOS and Android frequently call this domain, I wasn't able to find any official references or documentation on it, but it appears to be used for telemetry based off this Czech forum post -annotation=anonymous_feedback_submit_apicka_apkey=AIzaSejQEszExuVHsgk8YElDTlbbrhzeRISc --anenation=anonymous_feedback_submit_url=https://feedback-pa.googleapis.com/v1/feedback/products/1633926/web:anonymous_submit
growth-pa.googleapis.com
- I saw this domain was requested before in #44 & #2411, and it seems like it wasn't blocked due to the lack of information. However, I was able to find info on it, and it appears this domain is directly related to & used for promotions in Google's apps & services. See here from Chromium's source code, & here on Page 9:-const char kDesktopIOSPromotionQueryPhoneNumber[] =
- "https://growth-pa.googleapis.com/v1/get_verified_phone_numbers";
-
-const char kDesktopIOSPromotionSendSMS[] =
- "https://growth-pa.googleapis.com/v1/send_sms";
-
The Google Docs and Messaging apps (or a process on its behalf) connect to growth-pa.googleapis.com/google.internal.identity.growth.v1.GrowthApiService/GetPromos, sending device details but no unique identifiers
gvt2-cn.com
- Chinese variant ofgvt2.com
, which we already block, used for telemetry.gvt3.com
- Similar togvt2.com
, according to Google, this is used for "Google Play connectivity monitoring and diagnostics".locationhistory-pa.googleapis.com
- This is extremely difficult to find information on, but it appears to be related to Google's location history. I think it'd probably make sense to block this on the more aggressive tests. This might need more investigation though, unclear.locationhistoryaggregates-pa.googleapis.com
- Same as above.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: