Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Boiler Bosch Condens 8700i - error code H11/1021 #251

Closed
Nunak opened this issue Dec 20, 2021 · 18 comments
Closed

Boiler Bosch Condens 8700i - error code H11/1021 #251

Nunak opened this issue Dec 20, 2021 · 18 comments
Labels
enhancement New feature or request
Milestone

Comments

@Nunak
Copy link

Nunak commented Dec 20, 2021

Before creating a new issue please check that you have:

Completing this template will help developers and contributors help you. Try to be as specific and extensive as possible. If the information provided is not enough the issue will likely be closed.

You can now remove this line and the above ones. Text in italic is meant to be replaced by your own words. If any of the sections below are not relevant to the issue (for instance, the screenshots) then you can delete them.

Question
A clear and concise description of what the problem/doubt is.
I have question. My boiler random getting error "H11/1021 start: 2021.12.19 13:18, end: none" by Bosch service I got information that temperature sensor is fine.
My question is if this could be related to emsesp somehow ? I mean if is possible that emsesp could somehow inject this error code to boiler ?
The boiler is brand new and getting this error random but often and only solution is restart boiler. Reset errors from boiler will not reset this error.

Screenshots
If applicable, add screenshots to help explain your problem.
bosh-error

Device information
Copy-paste here the information as it is outputted by the device. You can get this information from http://ems-esp.local/api?device=system&cmd=info
EPS32, version v3.3.1b1

Additional context
Add any other context about the problem here.

@Nunak Nunak added the question Question about something label Dec 20, 2021
@proddy
Copy link
Contributor

proddy commented Dec 20, 2021

EMS-ESP is just reading the values. There are no write operations so don't expect EMS-ESP is interfering with the Boiler. Has this suddenly happened?

@bbqkees
Copy link
Contributor

bbqkees commented Dec 20, 2021

This sounds like an older issue with the outdoor sensor and the RC310 thermostat.
Is it the outdoor sensor that gives the error?

@Nunak
Copy link
Author

Nunak commented Dec 20, 2021

EMS-ESP is just reading the values. There are no write operations so don't expect EMS-ESP is interfering with the Boiler. Has this suddenly happened?

Yep it's happening suddenly I didn't found any interaction which could cause this .

@Nunak
Copy link
Author

Nunak commented Dec 20, 2021

This sounds like an older issue with the outdoor sensor and the RC310 thermostat. Is it the outdoor sensor that gives the error?

I have termostat Bosch CW400 with sensor outside. But what I found is a input sensor of heating water in boiler.

@bbqkees
Copy link
Contributor

bbqkees commented Dec 20, 2021

How often do you get the error?
If you remove EMS-ESP from your system, do you still get the error?
How long have you tested it?

@Nunak
Copy link
Author

Nunak commented Dec 20, 2021

How often do you get the error? If you remove EMS-ESP from your system, do you still get the error? How long have you tested it?

It's happening very randomly sometime twice per day sometime one per 3 days.
I didn't tested yet to remove EMS-ESP from the system.
I have EMS-ESP for years and this happenning only with the new boiler Bosch conedens 8700 with previous boiler Junkers ZBS 14 was without errors with the same termostat CW400 from bosch

Due to I am asking if this could happen due to EMS-ESP.

@bbqkees
Copy link
Contributor

bbqkees commented Dec 20, 2021

Try out by running your boiler for a few days without EMS-ESP connected.
If the error goes away, we should have a better look at it. If the error persists it's the boiler which is faulty.

@MichaelDvP
Copy link
Contributor

I've found H11/1021 is a faulty dhw sensor, the error is priority 16, low, reset only by reparing the fault.

What does emsesp shows as ww current intern temperature and ww storage temperature in fault state?

Last error shows the the first entry of error log from the boiler, restarting the boiler does not help, it's only that emsesp takes a while to read the information, but last error will reappear. Can you check the complete log by telnet command read 8 c2, i think we can see a list of the faults with starting times.

@Nunak
Copy link
Author

Nunak commented Dec 25, 2021

I've found H11/1021 is a faulty dhw sensor, the error is priority 16, low, reset only by reparing the fault.

What does emsesp shows as ww current intern temperature and ww storage temperature in fault state?

Last error shows the the first entry of error log from the boiler, restarting the boiler does not help, it's only that emsesp takes a while to read the information, but last error will reappear. Can you check the complete log by telnet command read 8 c2, i think we can see a list of the faults with starting times.

Sorry for late. There are answers

esmesp is showing temperature from "not working" sensor and temperature is changing
ems-esp1

There is output from read 8 c2

ems-esp:$ read 8 c2
000+00:15:17.437 N 0: [emsesp] Boiler(0x08) -> Me(0x0B), UBAErrorMessage3(0xC2), data: 08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 0F 18 32 00 00 00 00 00 08 C3 00 10 11 48 31
000+00:15:17.653 N 1: [emsesp] Boiler(0x08) -> Me(0x0B), UBAErrorMessage3(0xC2), data: 31 03 FD 95 0C 0D 13 12 95 0C 10 14 21 08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 14 12 (offset 27)
000+00:15:17.823 N 2: [emsesp] Boiler(0x08) -> Me(0x0B), UBAErrorMessage3(0xC2), data: 15 95 0C 15 12 27 08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 12 11 26 95 0C 15 11 09 08 (offset 54)
000+00:15:18.030 N 3: [emsesp] Boiler(0x08) -> Me(0x0B), UBAErrorMessage3(0xC2), data: C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 06 10 38 95 0C 09 10 21 08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 (offset 81)
000+00:15:18.245 N 4: [emsesp] Boiler(0x08) -> Me(0x0B), UBAErrorMessage3(0xC2), data: 03 FD 95 0C 0A 0F 15 95 0C 11 0F 0D 08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 13 0D 12 (offset 108)
000+00:15:18.417 N 5: [emsesp] Boiler(0x08) -> Me(0x0B), UBAErrorMessage3(0xC2), data: 95 0C 07 0E 2C 08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 06 0D 2E 95 0C 09 0D 22 08 C3 (offset 135)
000+00:15:18.619 N 6: [emsesp] Boiler(0x08) -> Me(0x0B), UBAErrorMessage3(0xC2), data: 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 0A 0B 18 95 0C 11 0B 19 08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 (offset 162)
ems-esp:$

Now I will try reset(via reboot of boiler) this new error and disconnect emsesp.

Thank you for your support!

@MichaelDvP
Copy link
Contributor

Here is the decoded error-log, always the same error, nearly daily:

boiler 08, ID C3 00, class 10(16dez), ?,  Code: H11/1021
08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 0F 18 32 00 00 00 00 00  2021/12/24 15:50 - now
08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 0D 13 12 95 0C 10 14 21  2021/12/19 13:18 - 2021/12/20 16:33
08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 14 12 15 95 0C 15 12 27  2021/12/18 20:21 - 2021/12/18 21:39
08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 12 11 26 95 0C 15 11 09  2021/12/17 18:38 - 2021/21/17 21:09
08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 06 10 38 95 0C 09 10 21  2021/12/16 06:56 - 2021/12/16 09:33
08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 0A 0F 15 95 0C 11 0F 0D  2021/12/15 10:21 - 2021/12/15 17:13
08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 13 0D 12 95 0C 07 0E 2C  2021/12/13 19:18 - 2021/12/14 07:44
08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 06 0D 2E 95 0C 09 0D 22  2021/12/13 06:46 - 2021/12/13 09:34
08 C3 00 10 11 48 31 31 03 FD 95 0C 0A 0B 18 95 0C 11 0B 19  2021/12/11 10:24 - 2021/12/11 17:25

Afaik the boiler also checks if the sensor data points to a bad thermal contact or wrong sensor position. If ww heating is active and the sensor-measurement does not rise instantly, the error is set.
Check the data if the start-times are correlated with ww-heating. Also check if the end-times are your manual resets.

@Nunak
Copy link
Author

Nunak commented Jan 14, 2022

Many thanks for your support. You were right. Error was ocuring also with disconnected emsesp board.

Issue was on the boiler on this part
wrong_part

What's interesting bosch know about this wrong part on every new boiler but they do not have enough of this spare part to replace it :o

You can close this question.

@MichaelDvP
Copy link
Contributor

Do you know what this part is doing? Or where it waas placed. I can't find part no. 200 79R04 in web.

@Nunak
Copy link
Author

Nunak commented Jan 14, 2022

Do you know what this part is doing? Or where it waas placed. I can't find part no. 200 79R04 in web.

Yep, not sure about the correct name but it's a code plug (socket) which is connected to main board of boiler. Connected from the right side. If you want I can take a photo.

@MichaelDvP
Copy link
Contributor

If you want I can take a photo.

If it's not much effort, please do.
Also your first picture shows a unknown device (i think it's the controller), can post here the device information like product-ID, etc. Then we can add it to the database.

@Nunak
Copy link
Author

Nunak commented Jan 15, 2022

If you want I can take a photo.

If it's not much effort, please do. Also your first picture shows a unknown device (i think it's the controller), can post here the device information like product-ID, etc. Then we can add it to the database.

Sure there is picture
IMG_20220115_104714

About the unkown controller that would be great.
There is picture of boiler
IMG_20220115_110814
I am using this boiler Bosch Condens 8700i W GC8700iW 30/35 C23. For controller I am using Junkers CW400
IMG_20220115_111539
Or you mean BBQ board ? I did [Order #923] (02/01/2020)

Thank you.

@MichaelDvP
Copy link
Contributor

Thanks, i've meant the device information shown on emsesp web page, the first sceenshot you've posted shows a unknown device: with mouse over you get the device information. Or download the system-info from help-page.

@Nunak
Copy link
Author

Nunak commented Jan 15, 2022

Thanks, i've meant the device information shown on emsesp web page, the first sceenshot you've posted shows a unknown device: with mouse over you get the device information. Or download the system-info from help-page.

There is system-info
emsesp_system_info.txt

@MichaelDvP
Copy link
Contributor

Thanks, as expected it's the controller (device-ID 0x09). We'll add the product id to database. Controllers do not have values, there is nothing more to do.

MichaelDvP added a commit to MichaelDvP/EMS-ESP32 that referenced this issue Jan 15, 2022
@proddy proddy added this to the v3.4 milestone Jan 23, 2022
@proddy proddy closed this as completed Jan 23, 2022
@proddy proddy reopened this Feb 19, 2023
@proddy proddy added enhancement New feature or request and removed question Question about something labels Feb 19, 2023
@proddy proddy closed this as completed Feb 19, 2023
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
enhancement New feature or request
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

4 participants