modbus register wrong?

[backuprestore]

Hi please check

ModbusItem(34102,"Betriebsstunden 2. WEZ",FORMATS.TIME_H,TYPES.SENSOR,DEVICES.W2),
ModbusItem(34103,"Schaltspiele 2. WEZ",FORMATS.NUMBER,TYPES.SENSOR,DEVICES.W2),

to my research this should be

ModbusItem(34102,"Schaltspiele 2. WEZ E1",FORMATS.NUMBER,TYPES.SENSOR,DEVICES.W2),
ModbusItem(34103,"Schaltspiele 2. WEZ E2",FORMATS.NUMBER,TYPES.SENSOR,DEVICES.W2),

vs.

also there are some more registers, like
33 106 input Verdampfungstemperatur
33 107 input Verdichtersauggastemp.

Parameter Elektrische Leistung Soll in W (0 … 30.000 W) 40002 Holding R/W
WBB_WP_ModbusTCP.xlsx

thank you for your work

[OStrama]

Thanks for the info! We‘ll change it in next release.
Much thanks also for the register info!

[thetschulian]

About elektrische Leistung:

I have no value in my dashboard for this

[OStrama]

Ahh yes, that‘s my Shelly Powermeter which measures the real heatpump consumption.

[thetschulian]

AH I see, okay, so with the

Parameter Elektrische Leistung Soll in W (0 … 30.000 W) 40002 Holding R/W

EDIT: ups, its Elektrische Leistung Soll and net the current Elektrische Leistung (IST)

[OStrama]

Exactly. As far as I understand it right, address 40002 allows setpoint specification for usage with PV-optimizaton. Means: The value can be adapted to optimize usage of PV energy. (High value when sun is shining, low val if not,..)

Up to now, I did not find a real electrical power signal from the HP. I guess they only estimate it from nominal values of the certain components. I wanted to know it exactly, so I installed a Shelly. If I compare it with the statistic values, it looks like this:

So I ask myself if it would make sense to add 0.5 to all statistical values to reduce the error of only taking the integer part..

[OStrama]

Have changed the register configuration and added the other values. The unknown ones as "?" without any translation. If we know more, they will be updated

[MadOne]

I think this is still wrong. Reopening it.
Additional info in #35

[OStrama]

At my WBB12 I only see useful values at Schaltspiele and active. Operating hours are always zero.
What do we have to change?

[backuprestore]

The Unit is Hour … so it‘s possible that your wbb12 did not reach this 1 Hour? You can Check in wem Portal or on the biblock (Fachmann -> Info -> 2 WEZ). Mine has Counted 17 Events With 0 Hours total

…

________________________________ Von: OStrama ***@***.***> Gesendet: Monday, November 18, 2024 7:00:47 PM An: OStrama/weishaupt_modbus ***@***.***> Cc: backuprestore ***@***.***>; Author ***@***.***> Betreff: Re: [OStrama/weishaupt_modbus] modbus register wrong? (Issue #20) At my WBB12 I only see useful values at Schaltspiele and active. Operating hours are always zero. What do we have to change? — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#20 (comment)>, or unsubscribe<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/BKKYHC7X63JMZKI6KIUM3JL2BITM7AVCNFSM6AAAAABQ2WJSP6VHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDIOBTG42TIOJXGY>. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[backuprestore]

So for me it's fixed with v1.0...

…

________________________________ Von: OStrama ***@***.***> Gesendet: Monday, November 18, 2024 7:00:47 PM An: OStrama/weishaupt_modbus ***@***.***> Cc: backuprestore ***@***.***>; Author ***@***.***> Betreff: Re: [OStrama/weishaupt_modbus] modbus register wrong? (Issue #20) At my WBB12 I only see useful values at Schaltspiele and active. Operating hours are always zero. What do we have to change? — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#20 (comment)>, or unsubscribe<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/BKKYHC7X63JMZKI6KIUM3JL2BITM7AVCNFSM6AAAAABQ2WJSP6VHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDIOBTG42TIOJXGY>. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[MadOne]

WEM:

[dhoeld]

@MadOne which firmware version is installed on your WBB?

[backuprestore]

@MadOne: did you checked this with a different modbus tool like ModbusTool of OpenModScan? Maybe Weishaupt is doing wrong: this is how it look at my side... but i can't check, because i didn't reach 1h in real live so 0 is ok for my device

[MadOne]

At least the value weishaupt has in wemportal is not on modbus.

[OStrama]

In Wem portal it‘s more than 10 hours..

[backuprestore]

i thing they don't but data in the register ... because documentation was also wrong with the description of reg 34102

meanwhile i'm reverse engineering the RS485 RTU bus...
https://github.com/backuprestore/weishaupt_modbus_rtu

problem: it's "single-master", so i can only listen... otherwise i get errors on the bus (and also some permanent and not erasable warning in WEM Portal - fun with warrenty). but i can get some nice infos like "rpm of the inverter" or "Druckgastemperatur" etc... so lot of hardware related information that is missing on modbus TCP side.

i'm not done yet because there are 2 different buses but i need to diassamble the front panel to get access on the "main-computer" for the second bus. will take some time.

best regards
Maik

[MadOne]

Impressive work, but for me personally it is not worth the effort.

[OStrama]

This is ho it is implemented today:

ModbusItem( address=34101, name="Status 2. WEZ", mformat=FORMATS.STATUS, mtype=TYPES.SENSOR, device=DEVICES.W2, resultlist=W2_STATUS, translation_key="status_2_wez"),
ModbusItem( address=34102, name="Schaltspiele E-Heizung 1", mformat=FORMATS.NUMBER, mtype=TYPES.SENSOR, device=DEVICES.W2, translation_key="schaltsp_e1"),
ModbusItem( address=34103, name="Betriebsstunden E1", mformat=FORMATS.TIME_H, mtype=TYPES.SENSOR, device=DEVICES.W2, translation_key="betriebss_e1"),
ModbusItem( address=34104, name="Status E-Heizung 1", mformat=FORMATS.STATUS, mtype=TYPES.SENSOR, device=DEVICES.W2, resultlist=W2_STATUS, translation_key="status_e1"),
ModbusItem( address=34105, name="Status E-Heizung 2", mformat=FORMATS.STATUS, mtype=TYPES.SENSOR, device=DEVICES.W2, resultlist=W2_STATUS, translation_key="status_e2"),
ModbusItem( address=34106, name="Schaltspiele E-Heizung 2", mformat=FORMATS.NUMBER, mtype=TYPES.SENSOR, device=DEVICES.W2, translation_key="schaltsp_e2"),
ModbusItem( address=34107, name="Betriebsstunden E2", mformat=FORMATS.TIME_H, mtype=TYPES.SENSOR, device=DEVICES.W2, translation_key="betriebss_e2"),
ModbusItem( address=44101, name="W2_Konfiguration", mformat=FORMATS.STATUS, mtype=TYPES.SENSOR, device=DEVICES.W2, resultlist=W2_KONFIG, translation_key="w2_konf"),
ModbusItem( address=44102, name="Konfiguration EP1", mformat=FORMATS.STATUS, mtype=TYPES.SENSOR, device=DEVICES.W2, resultlist=EP1_KONFIG, translation_key="adr44102"),
ModbusItem( address=44103, name="Konfiguration EP2", mformat=FORMATS.STATUS, mtype=TYPES.SENSOR, device=DEVICES.W2, resultlist=EP2_KONFIG, translation_key="adr44103"),
ModbusItem( address=44104, name="Grenztemperatur", mformat=FORMATS.TEMPERATUR, mtype=TYPES.NUMBER, device=DEVICES.W2, resultlist=TEMPRANGE_BIVALENZ, translation_key="grenztemp"),
ModbusItem( address=44105, name="Bivalenztemperatur", mformat=FORMATS.TEMPERATUR, mtype=TYPES.NUMBER, device=DEVICES.W2, resultlist=TEMPRANGE_BIVALENZ, translation_key="bivalenztemp"),
ModbusItem( address=44106, name="Bivalenztemperatur WW", mformat=FORMATS.TEMPERATUR, mtype=TYPES.NUMBER, device=DEVICES.W2, resultlist=TEMPRANGE_BIVALENZ, translation_key="bivalenztemp_ww"),

On my WBB12 I can see "Status E-Heizung 1|2" and "Schaltspiele E-Heizung 1|2" as well as "Grenztemperatur" and "Bivalenz WW". All others are not available or always 0.

Can you canfirm this on your installations? Or please let me know what to change. Otherwise I'll close this topic and add a nwe topic to get these values by other methods..

[MadOne]

For now i think we did everything right and the problem is on the weishaupt modbus side. Closing now.