Make overloads respect keyword-only args

This commit resolves python#1907.

Specifically, it turned out that support for non-positional args in
overload was never implemented to begin with. Thankfully, it also turned
out the bulk of the logic we wanted was already implemented within
`mypy.subtypes.is_callable_subtype`. Rather then re-implementing that
code, this commit refactors that method to support any kind of check,
instead of specifically subtype checks.

This, as a side-effect, ended up making some partial progress towards
python#4159 -- this is because unlike
the existing checks, `mypy.subtypes.is_callable_subtype` *doesn't* erase
types and has better support for typevars in general.

The reason this commit does not fully remove type erasure from overload
checks is because the new implementation still calls
`mypy.meet.is_overlapping_types` which *does* perform erasure. But
fixing that seemed out-of-scope for this commit, so I stopped here.

mypy/checker.py

@@ -20,7 +20,7 @@
     Context, Decorator, PrintStmt, BreakStmt, PassStmt, ContinueStmt,
     ComparisonExpr, StarExpr, EllipsisExpr, RefExpr, PromoteExpr,
     Import, ImportFrom, ImportAll, ImportBase,
-    ARG_POS, ARG_STAR, LITERAL_TYPE, MDEF, GDEF,
+    ARG_POS, ARG_STAR, ARG_NAMED, ARG_NAMED_OPT, LITERAL_TYPE, MDEF, GDEF,
     CONTRAVARIANT, COVARIANT, INVARIANT,
 )
 from mypy import nodes
@@ -39,7 +39,7 @@
 from mypy import messages
 from mypy.subtypes import (
     is_subtype, is_equivalent, is_proper_subtype, is_more_precise,
-    restrict_subtype_away, is_subtype_ignoring_tvars, is_callable_subtype,
+    restrict_subtype_away, is_subtype_ignoring_tvars, is_callable_compatible,
     unify_generic_callable, find_member
 )
 from mypy.maptype import map_instance_to_supertype
@@ -437,7 +437,8 @@ def check_overlapping_overloads(self, defn: OverloadedFuncDef) -> None:
 
                 assert isinstance(impl_type, CallableType)
                 assert isinstance(sig1, CallableType)
-                if not is_callable_subtype(impl_type, sig1, ignore_return=True):
+                if not is_callable_compatible(impl_type, sig1,
+                                              is_compat=is_subtype, ignore_return=True):
                     self.msg.overloaded_signatures_arg_specific(i + 1, defn.impl)
                 impl_type_subst = impl_type
                 if impl_type.variables:
@@ -3533,37 +3534,45 @@ def is_unsafe_overlapping_signatures(signature: Type, other: Type) -> bool:
     """
     if isinstance(signature, CallableType):
         if isinstance(other, CallableType):
-            # TODO varargs
-            # TODO keyword args
-            # TODO erasure
             # TODO allow to vary covariantly
+
             # Check if the argument counts are overlapping.
             min_args = max(signature.min_args, other.min_args)
-            max_args = min(len(signature.arg_types), len(other.arg_types))
+            max_args = min(signature.max_positional_args(), other.max_positional_args())
             if min_args > max_args:
                 # Argument counts are not overlapping.
                 return False
-            # Signatures are overlapping iff if they are overlapping for the
-            # smallest common argument count.
-            for i in range(min_args):
-                t1 = signature.arg_types[i]
-                t2 = other.arg_types[i]
-                if not is_overlapping_types(t1, t2):
-                    return False
+
+            # If one of the corresponding argument do NOT overlap,
+            # then the signatures are not overlapping.
+            if not is_callable_compatible(signature, other,
+                                          is_compat=is_overlapping_types,
+                                          ignore_return=True,
+                                          check_args_covariantly=True):
+                # TODO: this check (unlike the others) will erase types due to
+                # how is_overlapping_type is implemented. This should be
+                # fixed to make this check consistent with the others.
+                return False
+
             # All arguments types for the smallest common argument count are
             # overlapping => the signature is overlapping. The overlapping is
             # safe if the return types are identical.
             if is_same_type(signature.ret_type, other.ret_type):
                 return False
+
             # If the first signature has more general argument types, the
             # latter will never be called
             if is_more_general_arg_prefix(signature, other):
                 return False
+
             # Special case: all args are subtypes, and returns are subtypes
-            if (all(is_proper_subtype(s, o)
-                    for (s, o) in zip(signature.arg_types, other.arg_types)) and
-                    is_proper_subtype(signature.ret_type, other.ret_type)):
+            if is_callable_compatible(signature, other,
+                                      is_compat=is_proper_subtype,
+                                      check_args_covariantly=True):
                 return False
+
+            # If the first signature is NOT more precise then the second,
+            # then the overlap is unsafe.
             return not is_more_precise_signature(signature, other)
     return True
 
@@ -3572,12 +3581,11 @@ def is_more_general_arg_prefix(t: FunctionLike, s: FunctionLike) -> bool:
     """Does t have wider arguments than s?"""
     # TODO should an overload with additional items be allowed to be more
     #      general than one with fewer items (or just one item)?
-    # TODO check argument kinds and otherwise make more general
     if isinstance(t, CallableType):
         if isinstance(s, CallableType):
-            t, s = unify_generic_callables(t, s)
-            return all(is_proper_subtype(args, argt)
-                       for argt, args in zip(t.arg_types, s.arg_types))
+            return is_callable_compatible(t, s,
+                                          is_compat=is_proper_subtype,
+                                          ignore_return=True)
     elif isinstance(t, FunctionLike):
         if isinstance(s, FunctionLike):
             if len(t.items()) == len(s.items()):
@@ -3586,29 +3594,6 @@ def is_more_general_arg_prefix(t: FunctionLike, s: FunctionLike) -> bool:
     return False
 
 
-def unify_generic_callables(t: CallableType,
-                            s: CallableType) -> Tuple[CallableType,
-                                                      CallableType]:
-    """Make type variables in generic callables the same if possible.
-
-    Return updated callables. If we can't unify the type variables,
-    return the unmodified arguments.
-    """
-    # TODO: Use this elsewhere when comparing generic callables.
-    if t.is_generic() and s.is_generic():
-        t_substitutions = {}
-        s_substitutions = {}
-        for tv1, tv2 in zip(t.variables, s.variables):
-            # Are these something we can unify?
-            if tv1.id != tv2.id and is_equivalent_type_var_def(tv1, tv2):
-                newdef = TypeVarDef.new_unification_variable(tv2)
-                t_substitutions[tv1.id] = TypeVarType(newdef)
-                s_substitutions[tv2.id] = TypeVarType(newdef)
-        return (cast(CallableType, expand_type(t, t_substitutions)),
-                cast(CallableType, expand_type(s, s_substitutions)))
-    return t, s
-
-
 def is_equivalent_type_var_def(tv1: TypeVarDef, tv2: TypeVarDef) -> bool:
     """Are type variable definitions equivalent?
 
@@ -3624,26 +3609,22 @@ def is_equivalent_type_var_def(tv1: TypeVarDef, tv2: TypeVarDef) -> bool:
 
 
 def is_same_arg_prefix(t: CallableType, s: CallableType) -> bool:
-    # TODO check argument kinds
-    return all(is_same_type(argt, args)
-               for argt, args in zip(t.arg_types, s.arg_types))
+    return is_callable_compatible(t, s,
+                                  is_compat=is_same_type,
+                                  ignore_return=True,
+                                  check_args_covariantly=True,
+                                  ignore_pos_arg_names=True)
 
 
 def is_more_precise_signature(t: CallableType, s: CallableType) -> bool:
     """Is t more precise than s?
 
     A signature t is more precise than s if all argument types and the return
     type of t are more precise than the corresponding types in s.
-
-    Assume that the argument kinds and names are compatible, and that the
-    argument counts are overlapping.
     """
-    # TODO generic function types
-    # Only consider the common prefix of argument types.
-    for argt, args in zip(t.arg_types, s.arg_types):
-        if not is_more_precise(argt, args):
-            return False
-    return is_more_precise(t.ret_type, s.ret_type)
+    return is_callable_compatible(t, s,
+                                  is_compat=is_more_precise,
+                                  check_args_covariantly=True)
 
 
 def infer_operator_assignment_method(typ: Type, operator: str) -> Tuple[bool, str]:

mypy/constraints.py

@@ -525,7 +525,9 @@ def find_matching_overload_item(overloaded: Overloaded, template: CallableType)
     for item in items:
         # Return type may be indeterminate in the template, so ignore it when performing a
         # subtype check.
-        if mypy.subtypes.is_callable_subtype(item, template, ignore_return=True):
+        if mypy.subtypes.is_callable_compatible(item, template,
+                                                is_compat=mypy.subtypes.is_subtype,
+                                                ignore_return=True):
             return item
     # Fall back to the first item if we can't find a match. This is totally arbitrary --
     # maybe we should just bail out at this point.

mypy/subtypes.py

@@ -202,8 +202,9 @@ def visit_type_var(self, left: TypeVarType) -> bool:
     def visit_callable_type(self, left: CallableType) -> bool:
         right = self.right
         if isinstance(right, CallableType):
-            return is_callable_subtype(
+            return is_callable_compatible(
                 left, right,
+                is_compat=is_subtype,
                 ignore_pos_arg_names=self.ignore_pos_arg_names)
         elif isinstance(right, Overloaded):
             return all(is_subtype(left, item, self.check_type_parameter,
@@ -309,10 +310,12 @@ def visit_overloaded(self, left: Overloaded) -> bool:
                     else:
                         # If this one overlaps with the supertype in any way, but it wasn't
                         # an exact match, then it's a potential error.
-                        if (is_callable_subtype(left_item, right_item, ignore_return=True,
-                                            ignore_pos_arg_names=self.ignore_pos_arg_names) or
-                                is_callable_subtype(right_item, left_item, ignore_return=True,
-                                                ignore_pos_arg_names=self.ignore_pos_arg_names)):
+                        if (is_callable_compatible(left_item, right_item,
+                                    is_compat=is_subtype, ignore_return=True,
+                                    ignore_pos_arg_names=self.ignore_pos_arg_names) or
+                                is_callable_compatible(right_item, left_item,
+                                        is_compat=is_subtype, ignore_return=True,
+                                        ignore_pos_arg_names=self.ignore_pos_arg_names)):
                             # If this is an overload that's already been matched, there's no
                             # problem.
                             if left_item not in matched_overloads:
@@ -562,16 +565,22 @@ def non_method_protocol_members(tp: TypeInfo) -> List[str]:
     return result
 
 
-def is_callable_subtype(left: CallableType, right: CallableType,
-                        ignore_return: bool = False,
-                        ignore_pos_arg_names: bool = False,
-                        use_proper_subtype: bool = False) -> bool:
-    """Is left a subtype of right?"""
+def is_callable_compatible(left: CallableType, right: CallableType,
+                           *,
+                           is_compat: Callable[[Type, Type], bool],
+                           ignore_return: bool = False,
+                           ignore_pos_arg_names: bool = False,
+                           check_args_covariantly: bool = False) -> bool:
+    """Is the left compatible with the right, using the provided compatibility check?
 
-    if use_proper_subtype:
-        is_compat = is_proper_subtype
-    else:
-        is_compat = is_subtype
+    If 'check_args_covariantly' is set to True, check if the left's args is
+    compatible with the right's instead of the other way around (contravariantly).
+
+    This function is mostly used to check if the left is a subtype of the right which
+    is why the default is to check the args covariantly. However, it's occasionally
+    useful to check the args using some other check, so we leave the variance
+    configurable.
+    """
 
     # If either function is implicitly typed, ignore positional arg names too
     if left.implicit or right.implicit:
@@ -604,6 +613,9 @@ def is_callable_subtype(left: CallableType, right: CallableType,
     if not ignore_return and not is_compat(left.ret_type, right.ret_type):
         return False
 
+    if check_args_covariantly:
+        is_compat = flip_compat_check(is_compat)
+
     if right.is_ellipsis_args:
         return True
 
@@ -658,7 +670,7 @@ def is_callable_subtype(left: CallableType, right: CallableType,
                 right_by_position = right.argument_by_position(j)
                 assert right_by_position is not None
                 if not are_args_compatible(left_by_position, right_by_position,
-                                           ignore_pos_arg_names, use_proper_subtype):
+                                           ignore_pos_arg_names, is_compat):
                     return False
                 j += 1
             continue
@@ -681,7 +693,7 @@ def is_callable_subtype(left: CallableType, right: CallableType,
                 right_by_name = right.argument_by_name(name)
                 assert right_by_name is not None
                 if not are_args_compatible(left_by_name, right_by_name,
-                                           ignore_pos_arg_names, use_proper_subtype):
+                                           ignore_pos_arg_names, is_compat):
                     return False
             continue
 
@@ -690,7 +702,7 @@ def is_callable_subtype(left: CallableType, right: CallableType,
         if left_arg is None:
             return False
 
-        if not are_args_compatible(left_arg, right_arg, ignore_pos_arg_names, use_proper_subtype):
+        if not are_args_compatible(left_arg, right_arg, ignore_pos_arg_names, is_compat):
             return False
 
     done_with_positional = False
@@ -742,7 +754,7 @@ def are_args_compatible(
         left: FormalArgument,
         right: FormalArgument,
         ignore_pos_arg_names: bool,
-        use_proper_subtype: bool) -> bool:
+        is_compat: Callable[[Type, Type], bool]) -> bool:
     # If right has a specific name it wants this argument to be, left must
     # have the same.
     if right.name is not None and left.name != right.name:
@@ -753,18 +765,20 @@ def are_args_compatible(
     if right.pos is not None and left.pos != right.pos:
         return False
     # Left must have a more general type
-    if use_proper_subtype:
-        if not is_proper_subtype(right.typ, left.typ):
-            return False
-    else:
-        if not is_subtype(right.typ, left.typ):
-            return False
+    if not is_compat(right.typ, left.typ):
+        return False
     # If right's argument is optional, left's must also be.
     if not right.required and left.required:
         return False
     return True
 
 
+def flip_compat_check(is_compat: Callable[[Type, Type], bool]) -> Callable[[Type, Type], bool]:
+    def new_is_compat(left: Type, right: Type) -> bool:
+        return is_compat(right, left)
+    return new_is_compat
+
+
 def unify_generic_callable(type: CallableType, target: CallableType,
                            ignore_return: bool) -> Optional[CallableType]:
     """Try to unify a generic callable type with another callable type.
@@ -907,10 +921,7 @@ def visit_type_var(self, left: TypeVarType) -> bool:
     def visit_callable_type(self, left: CallableType) -> bool:
         right = self.right
         if isinstance(right, CallableType):
-            return is_callable_subtype(
-                left, right,
-                ignore_pos_arg_names=False,
-                use_proper_subtype=True)
+            return is_callable_compatible(left, right, is_compat=is_proper_subtype)
         elif isinstance(right, Overloaded):
             return all(is_proper_subtype(left, item)
                        for item in right.items())

mypy/types.py

@@ -774,6 +774,13 @@ def max_fixed_args(self) -> int:
             n -= 1
         return n
 
+    def max_positional_args(self) -> int:
+        """Returns the number of positional args.
+
+        This includes *arg and **kwargs but excludes keyword-only args."""
+        blacklist = (ARG_NAMED, ARG_NAMED_OPT)
+        return len([kind not in blacklist for kind in self.arg_kinds])
+
     def corresponding_argument(self, model: FormalArgument) -> Optional[FormalArgument]:
         """Return the argument in this function that corresponds to `model`"""