Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

On macbooks, the input never opens #7

Open
whoisarpit opened this issue Jan 20, 2025 · 5 comments · May be fixed by #8, #9, #10, #11 or #12
Open

On macbooks, the input never opens #7

whoisarpit opened this issue Jan 20, 2025 · 5 comments · May be fixed by #8, #9, #10, #11 or #12

Comments

@whoisarpit
Copy link
Owner

No description provided.

This was referenced Jan 21, 2025
Open
Open
Open
Open
Open
@patched-codes patched.codes
Copy link

patched-codes bot commented Feb 13, 2025

Issue: File Input Not Opening on MacBooks

Problem Description

The current file input functionality is not working as expected on MacBook devices. When users attempt to open the file input, nothing happens, preventing them from selecting files. This issue appears to be specific to macOS and is not observed on other operating systems.

Technical Details

  • Affected Platform: macOS (MacBooks)
  • Component: File picker functionality
  • Relevant Files:
    • src/pickFile.js
    • src/index.js

Impact

This issue significantly hampers user experience for MacBook users, preventing them from uploading or selecting files. It may lead to decreased productivity and frustration among our macOS user base.

Technical Analysis

  1. The openFilePicker function in src/pickFile.js is responsible for handling file selection.
  2. The function uses a click() method to programmatically trigger the file input.
  3. There might be a macOS-specific behavior or security restriction preventing the click() method from working as expected.

Proposed Solution

  1. Investigate macOS-specific handling of programmatic file input triggers.
  2. Consider implementing a fallback method for macOS:
    • Use a visible, styled button for file selection on macOS.
    • Implement feature detection to determine if the current method works, and if not, fall back to the visible button approach.

Action Items

  1. Research: Investigate macOS security policies and known issues with programmatic file input triggering.
  2. Testing: Set up a test environment with various macOS versions to reproduce and analyze the issue.
  3. Code Review: Thoroughly review src/pickFile.js and src/index.js to identify any potential OS-specific issues.
  4. Implementation:
    • Modify openFilePicker function to include OS detection.
    • Implement a fallback method for macOS users.
    • Add error handling and logging to capture any related issues.
  5. Cross-browser Testing: Ensure the solution works across all supported browsers on macOS.
  6. Documentation: Update README.md with any new usage instructions or known limitations.

Additional Notes

  • Consider reaching out to the open-source community or Apple's developer forums for insights on macOS-specific file input handling.
  • Ensure that any changes maintain compatibility with other operating systems.

Acceptance Criteria

  1. File input opens and functions correctly on MacBooks across supported macOS versions.
  2. The solution does not negatively impact functionality on other operating systems.
  3. User experience remains consistent and intuitive across all platforms.
  4. Proper error handling and user feedback are implemented for any edge cases.

Please assign this ticket to a developer with experience in cross-platform web development and macOS-specific issues. Regular updates on progress and any roadblocks encountered would be appreciated.

@patched-codes patched.codes
Copy link

patched-codes bot commented Feb 13, 2025

Issue: File Input Not Opening on MacBooks

Problem Description

The file input functionality is not working as expected on MacBook devices. When users attempt to open the file input, nothing happens, preventing them from selecting files. This issue appears to be specific to macOS and is not observed on other operating systems.

Technical Specifications

  • Affected Platform: macOS (MacBooks)
  • Component: File picker functionality
  • Relevant Files:
    • src/pickFile.js
    • src/index.js
  • Key Function: openFilePicker in src/pickFile.js

Impact

This issue significantly hampers user experience for MacBook users, preventing them from uploading or selecting files. It may lead to decreased productivity and frustration among our macOS user base, potentially affecting user retention and satisfaction.

Technical Analysis

  1. The openFilePicker function in src/pickFile.js is responsible for handling file selection.
  2. The function uses a click() method to programmatically trigger the file input.
  3. There might be a macOS-specific behavior or security restriction preventing the click() method from working as expected.
  4. The issue may be related to how macOS handles programmatic file input triggers or potential conflicts with the cloakStyle parameter.

Proposed Solution

  1. Implement OS detection in the openFilePicker function: 
    const isMacOS = /Mac OS X/.test(navigator.userAgent);
  2. Create a fallback method for macOS:
    • Use a visible, styled button for file selection on macOS.
    • Implement feature detection to determine if the current method works, and if not, fall back to the visible button approach.
  3. Modify the openFilePicker function to handle macOS differently: 
    function openFilePicker(cloakStyle, options = {}) {
  const isMacOS = /Mac OS X/.test(navigator.userAgent);
  if (isMacOS) {
    // Implement macOS-specific file picker logic
  } else {
    // Existing logic for other operating systems
  }
}
  4. Add error handling and logging to capture any related issues.

Action Items

  1. Research:
    • Investigate macOS security policies and known issues with programmatic file input triggering.
    • Explore alternative methods for file selection on macOS.
  2. Testing:
    • Set up a test environment with various macOS versions to reproduce and analyze the issue.
    • Create test cases for different scenarios on macOS and other operating systems.
  3. Code Review:
    • Thoroughly review src/pickFile.js and src/index.js to identify any potential OS-specific issues.
    • Assess the impact of proposed changes on existing functionality.
  4. Implementation:
    • Modify openFilePicker function to include OS detection.
    • Implement a fallback method for macOS users.
    • Add error handling and logging to capture any related issues.
    • Update src/index.js to accommodate any changes in the file picker implementation.
  5. Cross-browser Testing:
    • Ensure the solution works across all supported browsers on macOS.
    • Verify that the changes do not negatively impact functionality on other operating systems.
  6. Documentation:
    • Update README.md with any new usage instructions or known limitations.
    • Add inline code comments explaining the macOS-specific handling.

Additional Considerations

  • Performance impact of OS detection and potential fallback methods.
  • Accessibility considerations for any new UI elements introduced.
  • Backward compatibility with existing implementations using the library.

Acceptance Criteria

  1. File input opens and functions correctly on MacBooks across supported macOS versions.
  2. The solution does not negatively impact functionality on other operating systems.
  3. User experience remains consistent and intuitive across all platforms.
  4. Proper error handling and user feedback are implemented for any edge cases.
  5. Documentation is updated to reflect any changes in usage or limitations.

Please assign this ticket to a developer with experience in cross-platform web development and macOS-specific issues. Regular updates on progress and any roadblocks encountered would be appreciated.

@patched-codes patched.codes
Copy link

patched-codes bot commented Feb 13, 2025

Issue: File Input Not Opening on MacBooks

Problem Description

The file input functionality is not working as expected on MacBook devices. When users attempt to open the file input, nothing happens, preventing them from selecting files. This issue appears to be specific to macOS and is not observed on other operating systems.

Technical Specifications

  • Affected Platform: macOS (MacBooks)
  • Component: File picker functionality
  • Relevant Files:
    • src/pickFile.js
    • src/index.js
  • Key Function: openFilePicker in src/pickFile.js
  • Browser Compatibility: To be verified across different browsers on macOS

Impact

This issue significantly hampers user experience for MacBook users, preventing them from uploading or selecting files. It may lead to decreased productivity and frustration among our macOS user base, potentially affecting user retention and satisfaction.

Technical Analysis

  1. The openFilePicker function in src/pickFile.js is responsible for handling file selection.
  2. The function uses a click() method to programmatically trigger the file input.
  3. There might be a macOS-specific behavior or security restriction preventing the click() method from working as expected.
  4. The issue may be related to how macOS handles programmatic file input triggers or potential conflicts with the cloakStyle parameter.

Proposed Solution

  1. Implement OS detection in the openFilePicker function: 
    const isMacOS = /Mac OS X/.test(navigator.userAgent);
  2. Create a fallback method for macOS:
    • Use a visible, styled button for file selection on macOS.
    • Implement feature detection to determine if the current method works, and if not, fall back to the visible button approach.
  3. Modify the openFilePicker function to handle macOS differently: 
    function openFilePicker(cloakStyle, options = {}) {
  const isMacOS = /Mac OS X/.test(navigator.userAgent);
  if (isMacOS) {
    // Implement macOS-specific file picker logic
  } else {
    // Existing logic for other operating systems
  }
}
  4. Add error handling and logging to capture any related issues.

Action Items

  1. Research:
    • Investigate macOS security policies and known issues with programmatic file input triggering.
    • Explore alternative methods for file selection on macOS.
  2. Testing:
    • Set up a test environment with various macOS versions to reproduce and analyze the issue.
    • Create test cases for different scenarios on macOS and other operating systems.
  3. Code Review:
    • Thoroughly review src/pickFile.js and src/index.js to identify any potential OS-specific issues.
    • Assess the impact of proposed changes on existing functionality.
  4. Implementation:
    • Modify openFilePicker function to include OS detection.
    • Implement a fallback method for macOS users.
    • Add error handling and logging to capture any related issues.
    • Update src/index.js to accommodate any changes in the file picker implementation.
  5. Cross-browser Testing:
    • Ensure the solution works across all supported browsers on macOS.
    • Verify that the changes do not negatively impact functionality on other operating systems.
  6. Documentation:
    • Update README.md with any new usage instructions or known limitations.
    • Add inline code comments explaining the macOS-specific handling.

Additional Considerations

  • Performance impact of OS detection and potential fallback methods.
  • Accessibility considerations for any new UI elements introduced.
  • Backward compatibility with existing implementations using the library.

Acceptance Criteria

  1. File input opens and functions correctly on MacBooks across supported macOS versions.
  2. The solution does not negatively impact functionality on other operating systems.
  3. User experience remains consistent and intuitive across all platforms.
  4. Proper error handling and user feedback are implemented for any edge cases.
  5. Documentation is updated to reflect any changes in usage or limitations.

Please assign this ticket to a developer with experience in cross-platform web development and macOS-specific issues. Regular updates on progress and any roadblocks encountered would be appreciated.

@patched-codes patched.codes
Copy link

patched-codes bot commented Feb 13, 2025

Issue: File Input Not Opening on MacBooks

Problem Description

The file input functionality is not working as expected on MacBook devices. When users attempt to open the file input, nothing happens, preventing them from selecting files. This issue appears to be specific to macOS and is not observed on other operating systems.

Technical Specifications

  • Affected Platform: macOS (MacBooks)
  • Component: File picker functionality
  • Relevant Files:
    • src/pickFile.js
    • src/index.js
  • Key Function: openFilePicker in src/pickFile.js
  • Browser Compatibility: To be verified across different browsers on macOS
  • Dependencies: None identified in package.json that directly relate to file picking

Impact

This issue significantly hampers user experience for MacBook users, preventing them from uploading or selecting files. It may lead to decreased productivity and frustration among our macOS user base, potentially affecting user retention and satisfaction. Given that MacBooks represent a significant portion of our user base, this issue is considered high priority.

Technical Analysis

  1. The openFilePicker function in src/pickFile.js is responsible for handling file selection.
  2. The function uses a click() method to programmatically trigger the file input.
  3. There might be a macOS-specific behavior or security restriction preventing the click() method from working as expected.
  4. The issue may be related to how macOS handles programmatic file input triggers or potential conflicts with the cloakStyle parameter.
  5. The current implementation does not include any OS-specific checks or fallback mechanisms.

Proposed Solution

  1. Implement OS detection in the openFilePicker function: 
    const isMacOS = /Mac OS X/.test(navigator.userAgent);
  2. Create a fallback method for macOS:
    • Use a visible, styled button for file selection on macOS.
    • Implement feature detection to determine if the current method works, and if not, fall back to the visible button approach.
  3. Modify the openFilePicker function to handle macOS differently: 
    function openFilePicker(cloakStyle, options = {}) {
  const isMacOS = /Mac OS X/.test(navigator.userAgent);
  if (isMacOS) {
    // Implement macOS-specific file picker logic
    return new Promise((resolve) => {
      const input = document.createElement('input');
      input.type = 'file';
      input.style.display = 'none';
      document.body.appendChild(input);
      input.click();
      input.onchange = () => {
        resolve(input.files);
        document.body.removeChild(input);
      };
    });
  } else {
    // Existing logic for other operating systems
  }
}
  4. Add error handling and logging to capture any related issues.
  5. Update the pick function in src/index.js to accommodate the new macOS-specific logic.

Action Items

  1. Research:

    • Investigate macOS security policies and known issues with programmatic file input triggering.
    • Explore alternative methods for file selection on macOS.
    • Review Apple's developer documentation for any relevant guidelines.

  2. Testing:

    • Set up a test environment with various macOS versions (10.14+) to reproduce and analyze the issue.
    • Create test cases for different scenarios on macOS and other operating systems.
    • Test with popular browsers on macOS (Safari, Chrome, Firefox).

  3. Code Review:

    • Thoroughly review src/pickFile.js and src/index.js to identify any potential OS-specific issues.
    • Assess the impact of proposed changes on existing functionality.

  4. Implementation:

    • Modify openFilePicker function to include OS detection.
    • Implement a fallback method for macOS users.
    • Add error handling and logging to capture any related issues.
    • Update src/index.js to accommodate any changes in the file picker implementation.

  5. Cross-browser Testing:

    • Ensure the solution works across all supported browsers on macOS.
    • Verify that the changes do not negatively impact functionality on other operating systems.

  6. Documentation:

    • Update README.md with any new usage instructions or known limitations.
    • Add inline code comments explaining the macOS-specific handling.
    • Update any relevant API documentation.

Additional Considerations

  • Performance impact of OS detection and potential fallback methods.
  • Accessibility considerations for any new UI elements introduced.
  • Backward compatibility with existing implementations using the library.
  • Consider adding automated tests specifically for macOS scenarios.

Acceptance Criteria

  1. File input opens and functions correctly on MacBooks across supported macOS versions (10.14+).
  2. The solution does not negatively impact functionality on other operating systems.
  3. User experience remains consistent and intuitive across all platforms.
  4. Proper error handling and user feedback are implemented for any edge cases.
  5. Documentation is updated to reflect any changes in usage or limitations.
  6. Code passes all existing and new unit tests, including macOS-specific tests.

Please assign this ticket to a developer with experience in cross-platform web development and macOS-specific issues. Regular updates on progress and any roadblocks encountered would be appreciated.

@patched-codes patched.codes
Copy link

patched-codes bot commented Feb 13, 2025

Issue: File Input Not Opening on MacBooks

Problem Description

The file input functionality is not working as expected on MacBook devices. When users attempt to open the file input, nothing happens, preventing them from selecting files. This issue appears to be specific to macOS and is not observed on other operating systems.

Technical Specifications

  • Affected Platform: macOS (MacBooks)
  • Component: File picker functionality
  • Relevant Files:
    • src/pickFile.js
    • src/index.js
  • Key Function: openFilePicker in src/pickFile.js
  • Browser Compatibility: To be verified across different browsers on macOS (Safari, Chrome, Firefox)
  • Dependencies: No direct dependencies related to file picking identified in package.json

Impact

This issue significantly hampers user experience for MacBook users, preventing them from uploading or selecting files. It may lead to decreased productivity and frustration among our macOS user base, potentially affecting user retention and satisfaction. Given that MacBooks represent a significant portion of our user base, this issue is considered high priority.

Technical Analysis

  1. The openFilePicker function in src/pickFile.js is responsible for handling file selection.
  2. The function uses a click() method to programmatically trigger the file input.
  3. There might be a macOS-specific behavior or security restriction preventing the click() method from working as expected.
  4. The issue may be related to how macOS handles programmatic file input triggers or potential conflicts with the cloakStyle parameter.
  5. The current implementation does not include any OS-specific checks or fallback mechanisms.

Proposed Solution

  1. Implement OS detection in the openFilePicker function: 
    const isMacOS = /Mac OS X/.test(navigator.userAgent);
  2. Create a fallback method for macOS:
    • Use a visible, styled button for file selection on macOS.
    • Implement feature detection to determine if the current method works, and if not, fall back to the visible button approach.
  3. Modify the openFilePicker function to handle macOS differently: 
    function openFilePicker(cloakStyle, options = {}) {
  const isMacOS = /Mac OS X/.test(navigator.userAgent);
  if (isMacOS) {
    // Implement macOS-specific file picker logic
    return new Promise((resolve) => {
      const input = document.createElement('input');
      input.type = 'file';
      input.style.display = 'none';
      document.body.appendChild(input);
      input.click();
      input.onchange = () => {
        resolve(input.files);
        document.body.removeChild(input);
      };
    });
  } else {
    // Existing logic for other operating systems
  }
}
  4. Add error handling and logging to capture any related issues.
  5. Update the pick function in src/index.js to accommodate the new macOS-specific logic.

Action Items

  1. Research:

    • Investigate macOS security policies and known issues with programmatic file input triggering.
    • Explore alternative methods for file selection on macOS.
    • Review Apple's developer documentation for any relevant guidelines.

  2. Testing:

    • Set up a test environment with various macOS versions (10.14+) to reproduce and analyze the issue.
    • Create test cases for different scenarios on macOS and other operating systems.
    • Test with popular browsers on macOS (Safari, Chrome, Firefox).

  3. Code Review:

    • Thoroughly review src/pickFile.js and src/index.js to identify any potential OS-specific issues.
    • Assess the impact of proposed changes on existing functionality.

  4. Implementation:

    • Modify openFilePicker function to include OS detection.
    • Implement a fallback method for macOS users.
    • Add error handling and logging to capture any related issues.
    • Update src/index.js to accommodate any changes in the file picker implementation.

  5. Cross-browser Testing:

    • Ensure the solution works across all supported browsers on macOS.
    • Verify that the changes do not negatively impact functionality on other operating systems.

  6. Documentation:

    • Update README.md with any new usage instructions or known limitations.
    • Add inline code comments explaining the macOS-specific handling.
    • Update any relevant API documentation.

Additional Considerations

  • Performance impact of OS detection and potential fallback methods.
  • Accessibility considerations for any new UI elements introduced.
  • Backward compatibility with existing implementations using the library.
  • Consider adding automated tests specifically for macOS scenarios.

Acceptance Criteria

  1. File input opens and functions correctly on MacBooks across supported macOS versions (10.14+).
  2. The solution does not negatively impact functionality on other operating systems.
  3. User experience remains consistent and intuitive across all platforms.
  4. Proper error handling and user feedback are implemented for any edge cases.
  5. Documentation is updated to reflect any changes in usage or limitations.
  6. Code passes all existing and new unit tests, including macOS-specific tests.

Please assign this ticket to a developer with experience in cross-platform web development and macOS-specific issues. Regular updates on progress and any roadblocks encountered would be appreciated.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
1 participant
@whoisarpit