[bug] SystemTray shows the menu on LeftClick, it should be on RightClick only

[awkj]

Describe the bug

default SystemTrayEvent::LeftClick will show Tray Menu, I not found API or setting to disable the behavior.

https://tauri.studio/docs/guides/system-tray

use tauri::{CustomMenuItem, SystemTray, SystemTrayMenu};
use tauri::Manager;

fn main() {
  let tray_menu = SystemTrayMenu::new(); // insert the menu items here
  tauri::Builder::default()
    .system_tray(SystemTray::new().with_menu(tray_menu))
    .on_system_tray_event(|app, event| match event {
      SystemTrayEvent::LeftClick {
        position: _,
        size: _,
        ..
      } => {
        // the will auto pop Tray Menu
        println!("system tray received a left click");
      }
      SystemTrayEvent::RightClick {
        position: _,
        size: _,
        ..
      } => {
        println!("system tray received a right click");
      }
      SystemTrayEvent::DoubleClick {
        position: _,
        size: _,
        ..
      } => {
        println!("system tray received a double click");
      }
      SystemTrayEvent::MenuItemClick { id, .. } => {
        match id.as_str() {
          "quit" => {
            std::process::exit(0);
          }
          "hide" => {
            let window = app.get_window("main").unwrap();
            window.hide().unwrap();
          }
          _ => {}
        }
      }
      _ => {}
    })
    .run(tauri::generate_context!())
    .expect("error while running tauri application");
}

Reproduction

No response

Expected behavior

No response

Platform and versions

Operating System - Mac OS, version 12.2.1 X64

Node.js environment
  Node.js - 16.13.2
  @tauri-apps/cli - 1.0.0-rc.2
  @tauri-apps/api - 1.0.0-rc.0

Global packages
  npm - 8.1.2
  pnpm - 6.30.0
  yarn - 1.22.17

Rust environment
  rustc - 1.58.1
  cargo - 1.58.0

Rust environment
  rustup - 1.24.3
  rustc - 1.58.1
  cargo - 1.58.0
  toolchain - stable-x86_64-apple-darwin 

App directory structure
/dist
/node_modules
/src-tauri
/src

App
  tauri.rs - 1.0.0-rc.0
  build-type - bundle
  CSP - default-src 'self'
  distDir - ../dist
  devPath - http://localhost:3000/
  framework - React

Stack trace

No response

Additional context

No response

[amrbashir]

If you have a menu attached, why wouldn't you want to show it? just want to know your use-case.

IIRC, some platforms are hard coded to open a context menu when the icon is clicked (Linux and maybe macOS).

[awkj]

If you have a menu attached, why wouldn't you want to show it? just want to know your use-case.

IIRC, some platforms are hard coded to openn a context menu when the icon is clicked (Linux and maybeOS).

I found SystemTrayEvent::LeftClick and SystemTrayEvent::RightClick all will show tray menu.
but I wish leftClick will let my window display(from my custom function), now when I listen leftClick event, it will show tray menu and show my window at the same time, I want control default behavior of leftclick and rightclick.

[amrbashir]

I see, that's a valid use-case and one that I am interested into but you should know that tray click events on Linux doesn't work (limitation of Linux itself).

I will transfer this to Tao.

[amrbashir]

Ideally we want right click to show the menu without the left click.

[awkj]

Great!

[wusyong]

All applications I used will trigger the try both right and left clicks.
Telegram, Wireguard, and even system IME do this behavior.

[amrbashir]

It is good to follow the OS convention, but I remember @lemarier showed a demo of 1password app where LeftClick opens a window instead of a menu.

[amrbashir]

Alright, I will close this since it is the OS default behavior but If more people ask for this, we will reconsider.