diff --git a/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/scenes/SceneTagger.tsx b/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/scenes/SceneTagger.tsx
index 96dd2cc1d87..abd4ac52131 100755
--- a/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/scenes/SceneTagger.tsx
+++ b/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/scenes/SceneTagger.tsx
@@ -188,11 +188,20 @@ export const Tagger: React.FC<ITaggerProps> = ({ scenes, queue }) => {
     const [nbPhashMatchSceneB, ratioPhashMatchSceneB] =
       calculatePhashComparisonScore(stashScene, sceneB);
 
-    if (nbPhashMatchSceneA != nbPhashMatchSceneB) {
+    // If only one scene has matching phash, prefer that scene
+    if (
+      (nbPhashMatchSceneA != nbPhashMatchSceneB && nbPhashMatchSceneA === 0) ||
+      nbPhashMatchSceneB === 0
+    ) {
       return nbPhashMatchSceneB - nbPhashMatchSceneA;
     }
 
-    // Same number of phash matches, check duration
+    // Prefer scene with highest ratio of phash matches
+    if (ratioPhashMatchSceneA !== ratioPhashMatchSceneB) {
+      return ratioPhashMatchSceneB - ratioPhashMatchSceneA;
+    }
+
+    // Same ratio of phash matches, check duration
     const [
       nbDurationMatchSceneA,
       ratioDurationMatchSceneA,
@@ -213,11 +222,6 @@ export const Tagger: React.FC<ITaggerProps> = ({ scenes, queue }) => {
       return ratioDurationMatchSceneB - ratioDurationMatchSceneA;
     }
 
-    // Damn this is close... Check phash ratio
-    if (ratioPhashMatchSceneA !== ratioPhashMatchSceneB) {
-      return ratioPhashMatchSceneB - ratioPhashMatchSceneA;
-    }
-
     // fall back to duration difference - less is better
     return minDurationDiffSceneA - minDurationDiffSceneB;
   }
diff --git a/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/scenes/StashSearchResult.tsx b/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/scenes/StashSearchResult.tsx
index f2f20f8aa44..47b20417e01 100755
--- a/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/scenes/StashSearchResult.tsx
+++ b/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/scenes/StashSearchResult.tsx
@@ -5,12 +5,18 @@ import { FormattedMessage, useIntl } from "react-intl";
 import uniq from "lodash-es/uniq";
 import { blobToBase64 } from "base64-blob";
 import { distance } from "src/utils/hamming";
+import { faCheckCircle } from "@fortawesome/free-regular-svg-icons";
+import {
+  faPlus,
+  faTriangleExclamation,
+  faXmark,
+} from "@fortawesome/free-solid-svg-icons";
 
 import * as GQL from "src/core/generated-graphql";
 import { HoverPopover } from "src/components/Shared/HoverPopover";
 import { Icon } from "src/components/Shared/Icon";
-import { LoadingIndicator } from "src/components/Shared/LoadingIndicator";
 import { SuccessIcon } from "src/components/Shared/SuccessIcon";
+import { LoadingIndicator } from "src/components/Shared/LoadingIndicator";
 import { TagSelect } from "src/components/Shared/Select";
 import { TruncatedText } from "src/components/Shared/TruncatedText";
 import { OperationButton } from "src/components/Shared/OperationButton";
@@ -22,10 +28,25 @@ import { SceneTaggerModalsState } from "./sceneTaggerModals";
 import PerformerResult from "./PerformerResult";
 import StudioResult from "./StudioResult";
 import { useInitialState } from "src/hooks/state";
-import { faPlus } from "@fortawesome/free-solid-svg-icons";
 import { getStashboxBase } from "src/utils/stashbox";
 import { ExternalLink } from "src/components/Shared/ExternalLink";
 
+const getDurationIcon = (matchPercentage: number) => {
+  if (matchPercentage > 65)
+    return (
+      <Icon className="SceneTaggerIcon text-success" icon={faCheckCircle} />
+    );
+  if (matchPercentage > 35)
+    return (
+      <Icon
+        className="SceneTaggerIcon text-warn"
+        icon={faTriangleExclamation}
+      />
+    );
+
+  return <Icon className="SceneTaggerIcon text-danger" icon={faXmark} />;
+};
+
 const getDurationStatus = (
   scene: IScrapedScene,
   stashDuration: number | undefined | null
@@ -52,10 +73,12 @@ const getDurationStatus = (
   else if (scene.duration && Math.abs(scene.duration - stashDuration) < 5)
     match = <FormattedMessage id="component_tagger.results.fp_matches" />;
 
+  const matchPercentage = (matchCount / durations.length) * 100;
+
   if (match)
     return (
       <div className="font-weight-bold">
-        <SuccessIcon className="mr-2" />
+        {getDurationIcon(matchPercentage)}
         {match}
       </div>
     );
@@ -146,7 +169,7 @@ const getFingerprintStatus = (
       <div>
         {phashMatches.length > 0 && (
           <div className="font-weight-bold">
-            <SuccessIcon className="mr-2" />
+            <SuccessIcon className="SceneTaggerIcon" />
             <HoverPopover
               placement="bottom"
               content={phashList}
diff --git a/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/styles.scss b/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/styles.scss
index c54d939bfa7..38ae10652fd 100644
--- a/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/styles.scss
+++ b/ui/v2.5/src/components/Tagger/styles.scss
@@ -76,6 +76,12 @@
       background-color: #137cbd;
     }
   }
+
+  .SceneTaggerIcon {
+    margin-left: 0.25em;
+    margin-right: 10px;
+    width: var(--fa-fw-width, 1.25em);
+  }
 }
 
 .selected-result {