openGov support

[kianenigma]

I've raised this in DM a few weeks ago as well, but I am worried that it will be forgotten until the day that we upgrade Polkadot to open gov as well and there'd be no way to tip anymore.

To learn how to support this, all you have to do is follow more or less what I did here:

https://kusama.polkassembly.io/referenda/69

1. open gov proposal with small spender
2. submit preimage

---

@rzadp edits below

Things left to figure out

• Exact tip values corresponding to small/medium/large prompts
• Chain-specific decimals, maximum tips per track, etc - Polkadot vs Kusama
• Uploading tip (referendum) description
  • Either a polkassembly Description (off-chain),
  • Or a Remark (on-chain)
• Automatically detect whether the chain supports gov1 or opengov. Send proper one with a single command.

[kianenigma]

ping on this ^^ Open gov is coming to Polkadot (PR already open) and is being removed from Kusama. This will stop working soon.

[kianenigma]

any updates on this?

[parutger]

I think I figured out how to implement this, but I'm having some trouble creating a local testing setup for this. Can you help me, or do you know who can?

[rzadp]

Hey @kianenigma, just letting know that I have picked up this issue.
I will be posting updates.

[rzadp]

Hey @kianenigma @bkchr, do you have any preference on how the new bot prompt for OpenGov should work when it comes to the exact tip values?

The difference is that in OpenGov we have to configure the tip value ahead of time, whereas in gov1 it was outside of the scope of the tip bot.

I have two proposals:

Prompt	Behaviour
/tip {small,medium,large} or /tip {small,big}	The bot looks up a corresponding constant value
/tip <number>	The bot proposes the tip with the given value, automatically picking the correct track (Small Tipper / Big Tipper)

[bkchr]

Maybe all? Fixed numbers for small, medium and large and then also tipping some custom number.

[mordamax]

@bkchr, with custom number it's clear, but with fixed - question: since the limits of small track are different per relay-chain, for small/medium/large what values would you suggest?

kusama small tipper: max 8.3 KSM - so

• small: 2 KSM
• medium: 5KSM
• large: 8KSM

polkadot small tipper: 250 DOT

• small: 20DOT
• medium: 80DOT
• large: 150DOT

or any other numbers?

[kianenigma]

Suggested numbers make sense as prelude defaults, and then as basti said I think it should be reasonable to allow custom 42 to tip exactly this amount. I suppose you can still cap it to small tipper range.

[rzadp]

Hey @kianenigma @bkchr, just letting know that:

• The opengov changes have been implemented, so we'll be ready for the removal of treasury tips.
• We also implemented the custom numeric value for the tips.
• The changes are deployed to staging (not to production yet at the time of writing).

[bkchr]

Nice! Ty for the update!

[rzadp]

The changes are done and deployed to production.