[ERROR] not_allowed_token_type error on new bot app

[loretoparisi]

I have created a brand new bot app (21 feb 2020).
I the put my new bot oauth token in the init:

// Slack bot
                self.bot = new SlackBot({
                    token: self._options.slack.botToken,
                    name: self._options.slack.botName,
                    // (boolean, defaults: false) whether to open websocket connection to listen to incoming messages, 
                    // set to true for one time use
                    disconnect: false
                });

where the bot oauth token starts with xoxb-, but I get the not_allowed_token_type in the event

// slack bot error
                self.bot.on('error', (error) => {
                    error = error || new Error('slack connection error');
                    self.logger.error("Channel slack connection error", error.toString());
                    return reject(error);
                });

[sb39]

@loretoparisi did you get to know how to overcome this error ?

[loretoparisi]

@sb39 not yet, I have created a brand new app on the 21, according to slack on the 20th the new app oauth token have been deployed, so it should have work...

[bettysteger]

same issue: #145

[ntallapa12]

I am getting the same error, whats the status on this issue?

[thedesignchild]

Can confirm, same issue here too.. claims are that RTM is not allowed and that the issue can be solved if you make a simple slack app instead of a bot

[sb39]

I would recommend using Slack Official API, its much more flexible and very well documented

[baob]

Can confirm, same issue here too.. claims are that RTM is not allowed and that the issue can be solved if you make a simple slack app instead of a bot

I can confirm both that it's an existing issue AND that the workarounds suggested are fine. Here's what I said in the README of the app I'm building

Creating the slack app

MUST create CLASSIC slack app here and not the new style granular permissions app.
After that create a legacy app user then install the app to the workspace. Then the Bot Oauthh token will work.

Related docs:

• RTM docs has link at the bottom of the page
• SlackBots.js issue 145 documents the issue and workaround.
• node slack sdk issue 921 discusses in depth

[loretoparisi]

Hello, so what I did was this

• created a classic app ( I have followed the link above).
• created oauth persmissions for chat:write and app_mentions:read (this step was required, otherwise I could not install and create the Bot User OAuth Access Token.

Then I have set the Bot User OAuth Access Token in the SDK:

self.bot = new SlackBot({
                    token: self._options.slack.botToken,
                    name: self._options.slack.botName,
                    // (boolean, defaults: false) whether to open websocket connection to listen to incoming messages, 
                    // set to true for one time use
                    disconnect: false
                });

and I get that error again:

Error: not_allowed_token_type
    at /Users/loretoparisi/Documents/Projects/node_modules/slackbots/index.js:46:33
    at Array.<anonymous> (/Users/loretoparisi/Documents/Projects/node_modules/vow/lib/vow.js:773:56)
    at callFns (/Users/loretoparisi/Documents/Projects/node_modules/vow/lib/vow.js:24:35)
    at processTicksAndRejections (internal/process/task_queues.js:75:11)

So now my guess is that the classic apps are actually not classic apps anymore. Is there any way to check if the app is actually a classic app?

[loretoparisi]

[UPDATE]
Okay I have found the problem.
I cannot create a classic app anymore, BTW I had a classic old app (2015). I there fore chose the bot scope (deprecated scope), that is not available anymore to updated scopes apps:

and now it works!

So at least in my Slack, I cannot have not classic apps, but it works with a deprecated app.
I would keep it open, until it's not adapted to the new apps. I assume that the deprecation has a deadline, after that this workaround would not work anymore.

Thank you.

[baob]

A very full and clear explanation of how to setup a classic app on slack for RTM (for this workaround) from elsewhere:
slackapi/hubot-slack#584 (comment)

[loretoparisi]

@baob thank you. A question, maybe related to this classic app setup:

var params = {
     icon_emoji: ':rocket:'
 };
self.bot.postMessageToChannel(self._options.slack.botChannel, 'listening...', params);                    

the emoji does not appear in the slack chat. My fault?
Thank you.

[baob]

the emoji does not appear in the slack chat. My fault?

I suspect this s unrelated to the main topic of this thread. Two thoughts. (1) are you sure that emoji is available on your slack workspace ? (2) I remember seeing that initially but don't remember taking any specific action to cure it. Perhaps a caching issue ?

[loretoparisi]

@baob yes I have the :rocket: emoji in the workspace. I have also tried to remove the :

// slack bot ready
self.bot.on('start', () => {
    var params = {
       icon_emoji: 'rocket'
    };
    self.bot.postMessageToChannel(self._options.slack.botChannel, 'listening...', params);
    return resolve(true);
});

[loretoparisi]

I confirm now that the emoji works. The problem happens on slack in Chrome, while on slack mobile I can see emojis. Thanks!

[TomKulakov]

Are you guys ever planning to fix this? A few months later I have the same error after a fresh new project, and creating a new app bot.
I was following this tutorial. https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/building-a-slackbot-with-node-js-and-slackbots-js/
"slackbots": "^1.2.0"

[utricularian]

Bumping for visibility. Still cannot set fields

[Bear-Coding]

Are you guys ever planning to fix this? A few months later I have the same error after a fresh new project, and creating a new app bot.
I was following this tutorial. https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/building-a-slackbot-with-node-js-and-slackbots-js/
"slackbots": "^1.2.0"

Any fix for this? I was following the same tutorial

[esbenvb]

To anyone coming here:

The tutorial on freecodecamp is based on obsolete Slack APIs and a module that's not supporting the recent versions.

I just wasted time on this module and tutorial as well, it should have an "Unsupported" disclamer in top, IMO.

However, I made something work with Slack's own bolt API.

https://blog.logrocket.com/build-a-slackbot-in-node-js-with-slacks-bolt-api/