index.md

layout	student	organisation	organisation_link	project	project_link	tarball	mentors	phase	bio	social	email	blog	activity
report	Boxuan Li	coala	https://coala.io	Meta-review	https://summerofcode.withgoogle.com/projects/#5188493739819008	https://github.com/li-boxuan/GSoCReport/raw/master/li-boxuan_coala.tar.gz	[Hemang Kumar](https://github.com/hemangsk/) & [Surya Widi](https://github.com/blazeu) & [Andrew Dassonville](https://github.com/andrewda)	Bonding https://gitlab.com/coala/GSoC/GSoC-2018/milestones/14 Phase 1 https://gitlab.com/coala/GSoC/GSoC-2018/milestones/15 Phase 2 https://gitlab.com/coala/GSoC/GSoC-2018/milestones/16 Phase 3 https://gitlab.com/coala/GSoC/GSoC-2018/milestones/17	I'm a final year student (expected graduation date: May 2019) of Computer Science at The University of Hong Kong. I participated in GSoC and worked with [coala](http://coala.io) to implement a meta-review system, which collects and tracks GitHub reactions used by coala community to generate meaningful analysis. I also improved usability of [gh-board](http://github.com/coala/gh-board), a serverless kanban board, fixing some issues and extending it to track reviews & meta-reviews.	GitHub username li-boxuan link https://github.com/li-boxuan GitLab username li-boxuan link https://gitlab.com/li-boxuan Gitter username li-boxuan link https://gitter.im/li-boxuan LinkedIn username Li Boxuan link https://www.linkedin.com/in/li-boxuan-427510104	[email protected]	http://li-boxuan.github.io/	0 repo community link https://github.com/coala/community/commit/2929576df9c20144aad9db8a5e326c1853375158 details Set up meta_review app 1 repo community link https://github.com/coala/community/commit/aae015127c96b85a1cd9188199a6e4a46693d9f7 details Change meta-review models 2 repo community link https://github.com/coala/community/commit/78e1e3a542a1654982f55cde4e08bbf97ec81c3c details Implement meta-review scoring & ranking system 3 repo projects link https://github.com/coala/projects/commit/6c83d70a8559d1368fba1d80ad412b31ada7dad3 details [Bonding Period Work] meta_review.md: Add meta review project 4 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/16f8e84036a9ba47d434c60400da021d90a1a740 details [Bonding Period Work] fetch-issues.js: Build custom generator 5 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/46f1ad5ce83d5d72aa95ea00703b92c2fc38b2dc details [Bonding Period Work] Remove TODOs in components code 6 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/60b8a10f123d2bec71c22c31f3e281ad9609fa07 details [Bonding Period Work] Modernize existing React component code 7 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/e452f41ddda6abe149442d5240675b3ae3333e6a details nav.jsx: Fix broken link on header 8 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/77830f4146de9d4d29b539740423a0ca43ee219f details Pre-fetch pull request review comments & reactions 9 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/2a7338b3edff6d1c9f5b019ea07c28640996267a details package.json: Add linting on script & test 10 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/d3c6debe198b369901166be791a9ae53f23b26a0 details Get test suite working 11 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/671f13de1999001e718df9ce5187d7abf278791d details Set pre-fetch time limit for pull requests 12 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/91fffbbce1713a1d56276122d51cb16c7079b626 details Fix Travis failure 13 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/c33cc70bcab57a4ac13e4f352a255abc213dc874 details database.js: Fix `closed` filter bug 14 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/a2957290794424c6b8a0162ab49694cd771c2445 details .travis.yml: Enable keep-history 15 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/aca0d61832ffe1bac2b2c9d2615ea4219f68d3b6 details .travis.yml: Let moban task not deploy 16 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/4b82e679b83339f500d686967d3b6b843f7e1d40 details run-test.sh: Verify files exist 17 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/0f9f4a45bfdf341c5705d7543688adea7195c5cb details Increase test timeout threshold 18 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/34c2e6de21ed2933d8f19cca3b6dd177ce32c86f details login-modal.jsx: Add exception for default api url 19 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/828be376832687373b984df38ca71c1684651aa7 details Add `meta-review in need` column 20 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/ac8b0709b0e82963fd3d6680b37005359225effc details Display reactions of reviews 21 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/892b87ff808ac188166c9500d1169b1590b8d791 details dashboard.jsx: Add environment REPOSITORIES 22 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/e791bee60bf4af32aec889211d4de63d6418d7ed details Setup GraphQL client 23 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/5480420793979b9ae4b53117c6d5d757f12013bb details Use new graphql client to sync issues 24 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/93c842bca04298c8afc2d71d167efe04d432d11f details dashboard.jsx: Load repos automatically after login 25 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/9eae16877612d21f3ceed99ec23a097ec32e21b3 details Add review filters functionality 26 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/d32b25729ee1d9bc7972dce4a898a0bea9146098 details Refactor pre-fetching 27 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/faf793a3679ab32cb4e42c8ac54f174695b6bebc details github-graphql.js: Fix several issues 28 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/59e9cba6ca38a8fb6396a0864ff43bf749f1d6ec details Setup Jest configurations 29 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/8a3c49befc2c3d2b68ed11c5f2e217cb177caf57 details reactions.jsx: Add snapshot test 30 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/1f88cfa9c369f5b3f4bd7abafa6c15970196de80 details Add codecov 31 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/3638063072aeea1925bab5f9565d7765bf8d4cf4 details Separate test logic 32 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/10003d073c16c18da669b66f235c0e9abc1230f1 details netlify.toml: Verify pre-fetched files exist 33 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/d1a7ea3ea66c7af7a51a9717f67fc635fc35cf41 details Enhance meta-review UI 34 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/b062087825f01c1169accb646f0eaf0d1f0e7cb8 details Add reaction mutation functionality 35 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/d4705c5332ecd8e4329f0b62f7df3c9312c35a01 details repo-kanban.jsx: Use withAuth wrapper 36 repo gh-board link https://github.com/coala/gh-board/commit/d1a9bf25061800510cd9cf7d1c089900d2cbd1f1 details dashboard.jsx: Use withAuth wrapper 37 repo cEPs link https://github.com/coala/cEPs/commit/e9f7587856e1c236d37e96f54a0cb4d72069776d details cEP-0019.md: Meta-review system 38 repo coala link https://github.com/coala/coala/commit/dc2cc6a82f72644da55f509f8d4a50ba8fa694ba details Linter: Add option to remove 0 number 39 repo coala link https://github.com/coala/coala/commit/dfa92b64435b86b10b9a725ee32267896450e565 details Meta-review.rst: Add meta-review docs 40 repo coala link coala/coala#5704 details Newcomers_Guide.rst: Add meta-review process (pending review) 41 repo coala-bears link https://github.com/coala/coala-bears/commit/2f6f58b4afa0b139aa25062c3d3fcb27df3ea0d5 details PyLintBear: Fix column number convention 42 repo coala-bears link https://github.com/coala/coala-bears/commit/1f3325519a72cb98669185149b03b11c1ec25f70 details CPPLintBear: Fix line number convention 43 repo coala-bears link https://github.com/coala/coala-bears/commit/705f9db98d957cc9d27e675b1d58f369feb54255 details HAMLLintBear: Fix line number convention 44 repo coala-bears link https://github.com/coala/coala-bears/commit/e5df6bcac33aa06bec70bf21217972620c34e888 details WriteGoodLintBear: Fix column number convention 45 repo coala-bears link https://github.com/coala/coala-bears/commit/e445c04e28e95b7f21983e9e2dd770e81838aa69 details StylintBear: Fix column number convention 46 repo coala-bears link https://github.com/coala/coala-bears/commit/401fa883ffbe21b78a8a4899160592a293f3d4cd details CheckStyleBear: Fix offset convention

Meta-review

Work Done

coala community website now has a meta-review ranking list. coala gh-board website now has a column displaying review comments that need to be meta-reviewed. I also fixed many issues around gh-board repo. Apart from all above, I do some other contributions to the community, including doing reviews, and fixing several issues around coala & coala-bears repo.

Challenges

Most things went smoothly. The biggest challenge for me was that I did not have serious frontend experience. Before I applied for this project, I had no frontend development knowledge at all, while two thirds of my project was about javascript and React. Luckily, org admin and all my mentors were very willing to help and review my work. coala community always do extremely careful reviews and expect high quality of code. It was hard work for me, but I did learn a lot at the same time.

Work to be done

The ranking list on community website is very basic. It could be prettified and improved. As it is a ranking list, filtering, sorting & searching options could be added. The algorithm between that meta-review ranking system is basic: it uses naive iterative algorithm to calculate scores, which can be enhanced in the future.

There are still many issues around with gh-board. A major improvement which can be done is GitLab support - it currently only supports GitHub.