diff --git a/examples/TTW Practitioners Hub (Explainability)-2024-10-14T15-55-22.json b/examples/TTW Practitioners Hub (Explainability)-2024-10-14T15-55-22.json index fc8154e3..8f39f53f 100644 --- a/examples/TTW Practitioners Hub (Explainability)-2024-10-14T15-55-22.json +++ b/examples/TTW Practitioners Hub (Explainability)-2024-10-14T15-55-22.json @@ -1,459 +1,430 @@ { - - "type":"AssuranceCase", - "name":"TTW Practitioners Hub (Explainability)", - "description":"A partial assurance case for the TTW Practitioner's Hub. The assurance case focuses on the goal of explainable AI.", - "created_date":"2024-11-13T12:15:39.693060Z", - "lock_uuid":null, - "goals":[ + "type": "AssuranceCase", + "name": "TTW Practitioners Hub (Explainability)", + "description": "A partial assurance case for the TTW Practitioner's Hub. The assurance case focuses on the goal of explainable AI.", + "created_date": "2024-11-13T12:15:39.693060Z", + "lock_uuid": null, + "goals": [ { - - "type":"TopLevelNormativeGoal", - "name":"G1", - "short_description":"Predictions made by the AI system are explainable to end users.", - "long_description":"N/A", - "keywords":"N/A", - "assurance_case_id":204, - "context":[], - "property_claims":[], - "strategies":[ + "type": "TopLevelNormativeGoal", + "name": "G1", + "short_description": "Predictions made by the AI system are explainable to end users.", + "long_description": "N/A", + "keywords": "N/A", + "assurance_case_id": 204, + "context": [], + "property_claims": [], + "strategies": [ { - - "type":"Strategy", - "name":"S1", - "short_description":"Sub-argument for interpretable model", - "long_description":"Sub-argument for interpretable model.", - "goal_id":239, - "property_claims":[ + "type": "Strategy", + "name": "S1", + "short_description": "Sub-argument for interpretable model", + "long_description": "Sub-argument for interpretable model.", + "goal_id": 239, + "property_claims": [ { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P1", - "short_description":"The AI system utilises inherently interpretable models.", - "long_description":"The digital twin utilises inherently interpretable models.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":null, - "level":1, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[ + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P1", + "short_description": "The AI system utilises inherently interpretable models.", + "long_description": "The digital twin utilises inherently interpretable models.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": null, + "level": 1, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [ { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P1.1", - "short_description":"The models employed are transparent and understandable (e.g., decision trees, linear models).", - "long_description":"The models employed are transparent and understandable (e.g., decision trees, linear models).", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2171, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P1.1", + "short_description": "The models employed are transparent and understandable (e.g., decision trees, linear models).", + "long_description": "The models employed are transparent and understandable (e.g., decision trees, linear models).", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2171, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P1.2", - "short_description":"The decision-making processes of the models are easily traceable and explainable.", - "long_description":"The decision-making processes of the models are easily traceable and explainable.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2171, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P1.2", + "short_description": "The decision-making processes of the models are easily traceable and explainable.", + "long_description": "The decision-making processes of the models are easily traceable and explainable.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2171, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":324, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": 324, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P2", - "short_description":"The system provides mechanisms for model interpretation.", - "long_description":"The system provides mechanisms for model interpretation.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":null, - "level":1, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[ + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P2", + "short_description": "The system provides mechanisms for model interpretation.", + "long_description": "The system provides mechanisms for model interpretation.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": null, + "level": 1, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [ { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P2.1", - "short_description":"The system includes visualisation tools to illustrate how outputs are derived.", - "long_description":"The system includes visualisation tools to illustrate how outputs are derived.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2172, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P2.1", + "short_description": "The system includes visualisation tools to illustrate how outputs are derived.", + "long_description": "The system includes visualisation tools to illustrate how outputs are derived.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2172, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P2.2", - "short_description":"The system offers explanations in natural language.", - "long_description":"The system offers explanations in natural language.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2172, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P2.2", + "short_description": "The system offers explanations in natural language.", + "long_description": "The system offers explanations in natural language.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2172, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P2.3", - "short_description":"Interactive tools allow users to explore model predictions (e.g. counterfactuals).", - "long_description":"Interactive tools allow users to explore model predictions (e.g. counterfactuals).", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2172, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P2.3", + "short_description": "Interactive tools allow users to explore model predictions (e.g. counterfactuals).", + "long_description": "Interactive tools allow users to explore model predictions (e.g. counterfactuals).", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2172, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":324, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": 324, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P8", - "short_description":"Explanations are accessible to users with varying levels of technical expertise and abilities.", - "long_description":"Explanations are accessible to users with varying levels of technical expertise and abilities.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":null, - "level":1, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[ + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P8", + "short_description": "Explanations are accessible to users with varying levels of technical expertise and abilities.", + "long_description": "Explanations are accessible to users with varying levels of technical expertise and abilities.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": null, + "level": 1, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [ { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P8.1", - "short_description":"The system's explainability interface is compliant with accessibility standards (e.g., WCAG).", - "long_description":"The system's explainability interface is compliant with accessibility standards (e.g., WCAG).", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2191, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P8.1", + "short_description": "The system's explainability interface is compliant with accessibility standards (e.g., WCAG).", + "long_description": "The system's explainability interface is compliant with accessibility standards (e.g., WCAG).", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2191, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":324, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": 324, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"Strategy", - "name":"S2", - "short_description":"Sub-argument for transparent project governance", - "long_description":"Sub-argument for transparent project governance.", - "goal_id":239, - "property_claims":[ + "type": "Strategy", + "name": "S2", + "short_description": "Sub-argument for transparent project governance", + "long_description": "Sub-argument for transparent project governance.", + "goal_id": 239, + "property_claims": [ { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P3", - "short_description":"The project maintains comprehensive and accessible documentation.", - "long_description":"The project maintains comprehensive and accessible documentation.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":null, - "level":1, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[ + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P3", + "short_description": "The project maintains comprehensive and accessible documentation.", + "long_description": "The project maintains comprehensive and accessible documentation.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": null, + "level": 1, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [ { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P3.1", - "short_description":"Documentation includes detailed descriptions of model algorithms and their purposes.", - "long_description":"Documentation includes detailed descriptions of model algorithms and their purposes.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2174, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P3.1", + "short_description": "Documentation includes detailed descriptions of model algorithms and their purposes.", + "long_description": "Documentation includes detailed descriptions of model algorithms and their purposes.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2174, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P3.2", - "short_description":"Data sources, collection methods, and preprocessing steps are transparently reported.", - "long_description":"Data sources, collection methods, and preprocessing steps are transparently reported.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2174, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P3.2", + "short_description": "Data sources, collection methods, and preprocessing steps are transparently reported.", + "long_description": "Data sources, collection methods, and preprocessing steps are transparently reported.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2174, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":325, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": 325, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P4", - "short_description":"Decision-making processes within the project are transparent.", - "long_description":"Decision-making processes within the project are transparent.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":null, - "level":1, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[ + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P4", + "short_description": "Decision-making processes within the project are transparent.", + "long_description": "Decision-making processes within the project are transparent.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": null, + "level": 1, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [ { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P4.1", - "short_description":"Rationale for key design and development choices is documented and available to relevant stakeholders (e.g. end users).", - "long_description":"Rationale for key design and development choices is documented and available to relevant stakeholders.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2177, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P4.1", + "short_description": "Rationale for key design and development choices is documented and available to relevant stakeholders (e.g. end users).", + "long_description": "Rationale for key design and development choices is documented and available to relevant stakeholders.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2177, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P4.2", - "short_description":"Updates and changes to the system are communicated promptly to relevant stakeholders.", - "long_description":"Updates and changes to the system are communicated promptly to relevant parties.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2177, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P4.2", + "short_description": "Updates and changes to the system are communicated promptly to relevant stakeholders.", + "long_description": "Updates and changes to the system are communicated promptly to relevant parties.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2177, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":325, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": 325, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P5", - "short_description":"Accountability for the system's outputs is embedded in project governance.", - "long_description":"Accountability for the system's outputs is embedded in project governance.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":null, - "level":1, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[ + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P5", + "short_description": "Accountability for the system's outputs is embedded in project governance.", + "long_description": "Accountability for the system's outputs is embedded in project governance.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": null, + "level": 1, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [ { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P5.1", - "short_description":"Specific roles are assigned responsibility for ensuring the explainability and validity of outputs.", - "long_description":"Specific roles are assigned responsibility for ensuring the explainability and validity of outputs.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2180, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P5.1", + "short_description": "Specific roles are assigned responsibility for ensuring the explainability and validity of outputs.", + "long_description": "Specific roles are assigned responsibility for ensuring the explainability and validity of outputs.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2180, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P5.2", - "short_description":"Regular reviews and audits are conducted to assess and improve explainability practices.", - "long_description":"Regular reviews and audits are conducted to assess and improve explainability practices.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2180, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P5.2", + "short_description": "Regular reviews and audits are conducted to assess and improve explainability practices.", + "long_description": "Regular reviews and audits are conducted to assess and improve explainability practices.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2180, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":325, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": 325, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"Strategy", - "name":"S3", - "short_description":"Sub-argument for sufficient user engagement", - "long_description":"Sub-argument for sufficient stakeholder engagement.", - "goal_id":239, - "property_claims":[ + "type": "Strategy", + "name": "S3", + "short_description": "Sub-argument for sufficient user engagement", + "long_description": "Sub-argument for sufficient stakeholder engagement.", + "goal_id": 239, + "property_claims": [ { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P6", - "short_description":"End users are actively involved in the design, development, and deployment stages.", - "long_description":"Stakeholders are actively involved in the design, development, and deployment stages.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":null, - "level":1, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[ + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P6", + "short_description": "End users are actively involved in the design, development, and deployment stages.", + "long_description": "Stakeholders are actively involved in the design, development, and deployment stages.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": null, + "level": 1, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [ { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P6.1", - "short_description":"End users participated in focus groups to inform the structure and format of explainability mechanisms.", - "long_description":"Stakeholders and end users participated in focus groups to inform the structure and format of explanations.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2183, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P6.1", + "short_description": "End users participated in focus groups to inform the structure and format of explainability mechanisms.", + "long_description": "Stakeholders and end users participated in focus groups to inform the structure and format of explanations.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2183, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P6.2", - "short_description":"User studies determined that the end users are able to understand and explain the AI system's behaviour and outputs.", - "long_description":"User studies determined that the end users are able to understand and explain the AI system's behaviour and outputs.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2183, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P6.2", + "short_description": "User studies determined that the end users are able to understand and explain the AI system's behaviour and outputs.", + "long_description": "User studies determined that the end users are able to understand and explain the AI system's behaviour and outputs.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2183, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":326, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": 326, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P7", - "short_description":"Feedback mechanisms have been established for end users.", - "long_description":"Feedback mechanisms have been established for stakeholders and end users.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":null, - "level":1, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[ + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P7", + "short_description": "Feedback mechanisms have been established for end users.", + "long_description": "Feedback mechanisms have been established for stakeholders and end users.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": null, + "level": 1, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [ { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P7.1", - "short_description":"Invalid or inappropriate explanations can be flagged for review and investigation.", - "long_description":"Invalid or inappropriate explanations can be flagged for review and investigation.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2185, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P7.1", + "short_description": "Invalid or inappropriate explanations can be flagged for review and investigation.", + "long_description": "Invalid or inappropriate explanations can be flagged for review and investigation.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2185, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false }, { - - "type":"PropertyClaim", - "name":"P7.2", - "short_description":"Insights from user studies are used to refine and enhance future explainability features.", - "long_description":"Insights from user studies are used to refine and enhance future explainability features.", - "goal_id":null, - "property_claim_id":2185, - "level":2, - "claim_type":"Property Claim", - "property_claims":[], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":null, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "type": "PropertyClaim", + "name": "P7.2", + "short_description": "Insights from user studies are used to refine and enhance future explainability features.", + "long_description": "Insights from user studies are used to refine and enhance future explainability features.", + "goal_id": null, + "property_claim_id": 2185, + "level": 2, + "claim_type": "Property Claim", + "property_claims": [], + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": null, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "evidence":[], - "strategy_id":326, - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "evidence": [], + "strategy_id": 326, + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "in_sandbox":false, - "hidden":false + "in_sandbox": false, + "hidden": false } ], - "hidden":false + "hidden": false } ], - "owner":9, - "edit_groups":[], - "view_groups":[], - "color_profile":"default", - "comments":[], - "permissions":"manage", - "hidden":false -} \ No newline at end of file + "owner": 9, + "edit_groups": [], + "view_groups": [], + "color_profile": "default", + "comments": [], + "permissions": "manage", + "hidden": false +}